Democracy in America — Volume 1 by Alexis de Tocqueville

263. See the Digest of the Laws of Pennsylvania, at the words

1197 words  |  Chapter 30

County-rates and Levies, p. 170. In the State of New York each township elects a representative, who has a share in the administration of the county as well as in that of the township.] Such are the principal differences which the systems of county and town administration present in the Federal States. Were it my intention to examine the provisions of American law minutely, I should have to point out still further differences in the executive details of the several communities. But what I have already said may suffice to show the general principles on which the administration of the United States rests. These principles are differently applied; their consequences are more or less numerous in various localities; but they are always substantially the same. The laws differ, and their outward features change, but their character does not vary. If the township and the county are not everywhere constituted in the same manner, it is at least true that in the United States the county and the township are always based upon the same principle, namely, that everyone is the best judge of what concerns himself alone, and the most proper person to supply his private wants. The township and the county are therefore bound to take care of their special interests: the State governs, but it does not interfere with their administration. Exceptions to this rule may be met with, but not a contrary principle. The first consequence of this doctrine has been to cause all the magistrates to be chosen either by or at least from amongst the citizens. As the officers are everywhere elected or appointed for a certain period, it has been impossible to establish the rules of a dependent series of authorities; there are almost as many independent functionaries as there are functions, and the executive power is disseminated in a multitude of hands. Hence arose the indispensable necessity of introducing the control of the courts of justice over the administration, and the system of pecuniary penalties, by which the secondary bodies and their representatives are constrained to obey the laws. This system obtains from one end of the Union to the other. The power of punishing the misconduct of public officers, or of performing the part of the executive in urgent cases, has not, however, been bestowed on the same judges in all the States. The Anglo-Americans derived the institution of justices of the peace from a common source; but although it exists in all the States, it is not always turned to the same use. The justices of the peace everywhere participate in the administration of the townships and the counties, *h either as public officers or as the judges of public misdemeanors, but in most of the States the more important classes of public offences come under the cognizance of the ordinary tribunals. h [ In some of the Southern States the county courts are charged with all the details of the administration. See the Statutes of the State of Tennessee, arts. Judiciary, Taxes, etc.] The election of public officers, or the inalienability of their functions, the absence of a gradation of powers, and the introduction of a judicial control over the secondary branches of the administration, are the universal characteristics of the American system from Maine to the Floridas. In some States (and that of New York has advanced most in this direction) traces of a centralized administration begin to be discernible. In the State of New York the officers of the central government exercise, in certain cases, a sort of inspection or control over the secondary bodies. *i i [ For instance, the direction of public instruction centres in the hands of the Government. The legislature names the members of the University, who are denominated Regents; the Governor and Lieutentant-Governor of the State are necessarily of the number.—Revised Statutes, vol. i. p. 455. The Regents of the University annually visit the colleges and academies, and make their report to the legislature. Their superintendence is not inefficient, for several reasons: the colleges in order to become corporations stand in need of a charter, which is only granted on the recommendation of the Regents; every year funds are distributed by the State for the encouragement of learning, and the Regents are the distributors of this money. See chap. xv. “Instruction,” Revised Statutes, vol. i. p. 455. The school-commissioners are obliged to send an annual report to the Superintendent of the Republic.—Id. p. 488. A similar report is annually made to the same person on the number and condition of the poor.—Id. p. 631.] At other times they constitute a court of appeal for the decision of affairs. *j In the State of New York judicial penalties are less used than in other parts as a means of administration, and the right of prosecuting the offences of public officers is vested in fewer hands. *k The same tendency is faintly observable in some other States; *l but in general the prominent feature of the administration in the United States is its excessive local independence. j [ If any one conceives himself to be wronged by the school-commissioners (who are town-officers), he can appeal to the superintendent of the primary schools, whose decision is final.—Revised Statutes, vol. i. p. 487. Provisions similar to those above cited are to be met with from time to time in the laws of the State of New York; but in general these attempts at centralization are weak and unproductive. The great authorities of the State have the right of watching and controlling the subordinate agents, without that of rewarding or punishing them. The same individual is never empowered to give an order and to punish disobedience; he has therefore the right of commanding, without the means of exacting compliance. In 1830 the Superintendent of Schools complained in his Annual Report addressed to the legislature that several school-commissioners had neglected, notwithstanding his application, to furnish him with the accounts which were due. He added that if this omission continued he should be obliged to prosecute them, as the law directs, before the proper tribunals.] k [ Thus the district-attorney is directed to recover all fines below the sum of fifty dollars, unless such a right has been specially awarded to another magistrate.—Revised Statutes, vol. i. p. 383.] l [ Several traces of centralization may be discovered in Massachusetts; for instance, the committees of the town-schools are directed to make an annual report to the Secretary of State. See Laws of Massachusetts, vol. i. p. 367.] Of The State I have described the townships and the administration; it now remains for me to speak of the State and the Government. This is ground I may pass over rapidly, without fear of being misunderstood; for all I have to say is to be found in written forms of the various constitutions, which are easily to be procured. These constitutions rest upon a simple and rational theory; their forms have been adopted by all constitutional nations, and are become familiar to us. In this place, therefore, it is only necessary for me to give a short analysis; I shall endeavor afterwards to pass judgment upon what I now describe.

Chapters

1. Chapter 1 2. Chapter I: Exterior Form Of North America 3. Chapter II: Origin Of The Anglo-Americans—Part I 4. Chapter III: Social Conditions Of The Anglo-Americans 5. Chapter IV: The Principle Of The Sovereignty Of The People In America 6. Chapter VI: Judicial Power In The United States 7. Chapter VII: Political Jurisdiction In The United States 8. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part I 9. Chapter IX: Why The People May Strictly Be Said To Govern In The 10. Chapter X: Parties In The United States 11. Chapter XI: Liberty Of The Press In The United States 12. Chapter XII: Political Associations In The United States 13. Chapter XV: Unlimited Power Of Majority, And Its Consequences—Part I 14. Chapter XVI: Causes Mitigating Tyranny In The United States—Part I 15. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 16. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 17. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 18. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 19. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races In The United 20. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part X 21. Chapter I: Exterior Form Of North America 22. Chapter II: Origin Of The Anglo-Americans—Part I 23. Chapter II: Origin Of The Anglo-Americans—Part II 24. 1650. *p The legislators of Connecticut *q begin with the penal laws, 25. Chapter III: Social Conditions Of The Anglo-Americans 26. Chapter IV: The Principle Of The Sovereignty Of The People In America 27. Chapter V: Necessity Of Examining The Condition Of The States—Part I 28. introduction of judicial power into the administration—Consequence of 29. Chapter V: Necessity Of Examining The Condition Of The States—Part II 30. 263. See the Digest of the Laws of Pennsylvania, at the words 31. Chapter V: Necessity Of Examining The Condition Of The States—Part III 32. Chapter VI: Judicial Power In The United States 33. Chapter VII: Political Jurisdiction In The United States 34. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part I 35. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part II 36. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part III 37. introduction of physical force exceedingly rare, and is very frequently 38. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part IV 39. Chapter VIII: The Federal Constitution—Part V 40. Chapter IX: Why The People May Strictly Be Said To Govern In The 41. Chapter X: Parties In The United States 42. Chapter XI: Liberty Of The Press In The United States 43. Chapter XII: Political Associations In The United States 44. Chapter XIII: Government Of The Democracy In America—Part I 45. Chapter XIII: Government Of The Democracy In America—Part II 46. Chapter XIII: Government Of The Democracy In America—Part III 47. Chapter XIV: Advantages American Society Derive From Democracy—Part I 48. Chapter XIV: Advantages American Society Derive From Democracy—Part II 49. episode to the general activity—Difficult for an American to confine 50. Chapter XV: Unlimited Power Of Majority, And Its Consequences—Part I 51. Chapter XV: Unlimited Power Of Majority, And Its Consequences—Part II 52. Chapter XVI: Causes Mitigating Tyranny In The United States—Part I 53. introduction of an entire system of ideas peculiar to the counsel 54. Chapter XVI: Causes Mitigating Tyranny In The United States—Part II 55. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 56. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 57. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 58. Chapter XVII: Principal Causes Maintaining The Democratic 59. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races In The United 60. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part II 61. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part III 62. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part IV 63. 1830. But this proportion is perpetually changing, as it constantly 64. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part V 65. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part VI 66. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part VII 67. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part VIII 68. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part IX 69. 100. [These statements relate to a condition of affairs which has 70. Chapter XVIII: Future Condition Of Three Races—Part X

Reading Tips

Use arrow keys to navigate

Press 'N' for next chapter

Press 'P' for previous chapter