Treatise on Poisons by Sir Robert Christison
CHAPTER VII.
3376 words | Chapter 82
OF THE ALKALIS AND ALKALINE SALTS.
The second order of the class of irritants comprehends the alkalis, some
of the alkaline salts, and lime. The species which it includes are
little allied to one another except in chemical composition; and in
particular they are little allied in physiological properties. It
appears impossible, however, to make a better arrangement than that
proposed by Orfila, which will therefore be here followed.
Most of the poisons of the second order are powerful local irritants.
Some of them likewise act indirectly on distant organs; and a few are
more distinguished by their remote than by their local effects. This
order may be conveniently divided into two groups,—the one embracing the
two fixed alkalis with their carbonates, nitrates, and chlorides, and
also lime,—the other ammonia, with its salts, and likewise the alkaline
sulphurets.
The action of the first group is purely irritant and strictly local.
When concentrated, the fixed alkalis and their carbonates produce
chemical decomposition, softening the animal tissues, and reducing them
eventually to a pulpy mass; which change depends on their possessing the
power, as chemical agents, of dissolving almost all the soft solids of
the body. When much diluted, they produce inflammation, without
corroding the textures; and it does not appear that they are even then
absorbed in such quantity as to prove injurious to any remote organ. The
action of the alkaline nitrates and of lime is that of irritants only;
at least their chemical action is obscure and feeble.
_Of the Fixed Alkalis and their Carbonates._
_Section_ I.—_Of their Tests._
_Potass_ in its caustic state, as usually met with in the shops, forms
little gray-coloured cylinders or cakes which have a radiated,
crystalline fracture, and an excessively acrid caustic taste, and feel
soapy if touched with the wet finger. It deliquesces rapidly in moist
air, and then attracts carbonic acid from the atmosphere. It is easily
fused by heat, and is exceedingly soluble in water. The solution has a
strong alkaline reaction on vegetable colours, restoring reddened litmus
to blue, turning syrup of violets or infusion or red cabbage to green,
and rendering infusion of turmeric brown. It is distinguished from the
alkaline earths when in solution, by not precipitating with carbonic or
sulphuric acid, and from soda by the tests to be presently mentioned for
its carbonate.
_Carbonate of potash_ [subcarbonate, salt of tartar], is usually sold,
when pure, in small white grains, formed by melting the salt and
stirring it rapidly as it cools. In its impure state it is called in
this country potashes, and when somewhat purified, pearl ash. It has
then a mixed grayish, yellowish, or bluish colour, and is sold in
crumbly lumps of various sizes. In every state it is deliquescent and
very caustic. It cannot be crystallized. It gives out carbonic acid gas
with the addition of any stronger acid, such as sulphuric, muriatic, or
acetic acid. Its solution precipitates yellow with the chloride of
platinum, gives a crystalline precipitate with perchloric acid, when the
salt forms not less than a fortieth or fiftieth part,—is similarly acted
on by a considerable excess of tartaric acid, if the salt constitute
about a thirtieth of the fluid,—and yields with the soluble salts of
baryta a white precipitate soluble in nitric acid.
_Soda_ resembles potass closely in chemical as well as physiological
properties; and the _carbonate_ bears the same resemblance to the
carbonate of potass. The chief differences are the following. The
carbonate of soda is easily crystallized, and effloresces on exposure to
the air. A solution in twenty parts of water yields no precipitate with
either perchloric acid or an excess of tartaric acid, because there is
no sparingly soluble perchlorate or bitartrate, as in the case of
potash. Its solution is precipitated by antimoniate of potash, because
the antimoniate of soda is very sparingly soluble. All its salts remain
unaffected by the chloride of platinum, because their base cannot form
like potass an insoluble triple salt with the reagent. The acetate of
soda is permanent in the air, while the acetate of potass is one of the
most deliquescent salts known. In trying this last test, which is very
characteristic, care must be taken to avoid an excess of acid in the
acetate of soda by expelling it at a temperature of 212°, otherwise the
salt is as deliquescent as the acetate of potass.—Another difference is,
that the chloride of sodium, being nearly as soluble in temperate as in
boiling water, crystallizes with difficulty and but sparingly by cooling
a concentrated boiling solution; while the chloride of potassium is much
more soluble in hot than in cold water, and crystallizes easily and
abundantly when a concentrated boiling solution is cooled down.
_Process for Potash and its Carbonate in Organic Mixtures._—The
following method has been lately recommended for the detection of potash
and its carbonate in complex organic mixtures. Ascertain that the
mixture is alkaline in its action on litmus-paper and turmeric-paper,
and that it is not ammoniacal in odour. Distil to one-third; ascertain
that it has still an alkaline reaction, and evaporate to dryness in a
porcelain basin. Agitate the residue, when cold, with absolute alcohol;
boil, pour off the liquor, and filter it while hot. Repeat this with the
residuum and more alcohol. Distil off most of the alcohol, and evaporate
to dryness. Raise the heat to char the residuum, continue the heat as
long as vapours come off, remove the charcoaly matter, and incinerate it
for forty-five minutes in a silver crucible. Try to separate potash from
what remains by means of absolute alcohol; and if this do not succeed,
remove carbonate of potash by boiling water. In either case search for
potash by litmus-paper, turmeric-paper, chloride of platinum, and
perchloric acid.[429]
The conclusiveness of this process depends upon the fact, that absolute
alcohol cannot dissolve from solid organic substances such a proportion
of lactate, tartrate, acetate, sulphate, or phosphate of potash, or
chloride of potassium, as to be acted on by chloride of platinum or
perchloric acid.[430]—It is to be observed that carbonate of potash
singly is insoluble in absolute alcohol; but it becomes soluble in that
fluid, when it is conjoined with various organic matters. Hence it is
that this process, intended fundamentally for caustic potash alone, is
applicable to carbonate of potash also.
_Process for Soda and its Carbonate in Organic Mixtures._—These
substances may be separated by the method just described for potash. If
the alcoholic solution of the extract of the suspected matter be
alkaline in its action on litmus, and be afterwards found to contain
soda or its carbonate, the evidence of these substances having been
derived from without is satisfactory, because the carbonate of soda
contained in many animal matters cannot be so detached. But if no
indications of the presence of soda be thus obtained, it is not enough
that soda be found in the alcoholic solution of the incinerated
alcoholic extract, because the natural carbonate of soda of animal
matter may be separated in that manner.[431]
SECTION II.—_Of the Action of the fixed Alkalis, and the Symptoms they
cause in Man._
The action of the two fixed alkalis and their carbonates on the animal
system is so nearly the same, that the facts which have been ascertained
in respect to one of them will apply to all the rest. The operation of
potass and its carbonate has been carefully investigated by Professor
Orfila,[432] and by M. Bretonneau of Tours.[433]
When caustic potass is injected in minute portions into the veins, it
instantly coagulates the blood. Five grains, according to Orfila, will
in this way kill a dog in two minutes. But when small doses either of
potash itself, or its carbonate, or indeed any of its salts are used,
Mr. Blake found, that without coagulating the blood, they arrested the
action of the heart in ten seconds, if injected into the jugular vein;
and that when they were injected into the carotid artery, they
occasioned in four seconds signs of great obstruction in the capillary
circulation, and arrestment of the heart’s action in thirty-five
minutes, through means of this effect. Next to the salts of baryta he
thought the potash salts the most powerful on the heart’s action of all
those he tried.[434] When introduced into the stomach potash acts
powerfully as an irritant, and generally corrodes the coats of that
organ. Thirty-two grains given by Orfila to a dog caused pain in the
gullet, violent vomiting, much anguish, restlessness, and death on the
third day. On dissection he found the inner coat of the gullet and
stomach black and red; and near the pylorus there was a perforation
three-quarters of an inch wide, and surrounded by a hard, elevated
margin. The observations of Bretonneau are in some respects different.
When potass was swallowed by dogs in the dose of 40 grains, he found
that the animals, after suffering for some time from violent vomiting,
always died sooner or later of wasting and exhaustion; and that the
action of the poison was confined chiefly to the gullet, which was
extensively destroyed and ulcerated on its inner surface. But when the
gullet was defended by the potass being passed at once into the stomach
in a caustic holder, larger doses, even several times repeated, did not
prove fatal. The usual violent symptoms of irritation prevailed for two
or three days; but on these subsiding, the animals rapidly recovered
their appetite and playfulness, appearing in fact to be restored to
perfect health. Yet there could be no doubt that the stomach all the
while was severely injured; for in some of the animals, which were
strangled for the sake of examination several weeks after they took the
poison, the villous coat was found extensively removed, and even the
muscular and peritonæal coats were here and there destroyed and
cicatrized. Bretonneau farther adds, that ten or fifteen grains
introduced into the rectum caused death sooner than three times as much
given by the mouth.
The carbonate of potass possesses properties similar in kind, but
inferior in degree to those of the caustic alkali. Two drachms given by
Orfila to a dog killed it in twenty-five minutes, violent vomiting and
great agony having preceded death. The stomach was universally of a
deep-red colour on its inner surface.
Potash and its carbonate are absorbed in the course of their action, and
may be detected by Orfila’s process in the liver, kidneys, and
urine.[435]
The actions of soda and its carbonate seem on the whole the same with
those of potash; but they are not so energetic. In one respect however
soda and its salts differ most materially from those of potash. For
while the latter, when admitted directly into a vein, act by arresting
the action of the heart, soda and its salts, according to the inquiries
of Mr. Blake, have no such effect, but cause death by obstructing the
circulation of the pulmonary capillaries, and preventing the return of
blood from the lungs to the left side of the heart. This conclusion
seems to flow from the following facts. The respiration becomes in a few
seconds laborious and soon ceases, whilst the heart continues to beat
vigorously: arterial pressure is greatly reduced, while venous pressure
is much increased owing to accumulation of blood in the right side of
the heart: after death the lungs are found congested and often full of
froth: and the heart continues contractile, very turgid in the right
side, but quite empty of blood in its left cavities.[436]
Poisoning with the caustic alkalis is rare. In 1842, a lady suffering
from inflammation of the bowels took an ounce of solution of potass by
mistake for kali-water, or a solution of bicarbonate of potash
surcharged with carbonic acid. She suffered severely at the time, and
died in a fortnight, probably of the conjunct effects of her disease and
the poison.[437] This is the only case I have found in print of
poisoning with a caustic alkali. But the effects of their carbonates
have been several times witnessed, and appear to resemble closely those
of the concentrated mineral acids.
The symptoms are in the first instance an acrid burning taste, and rapid
destruction of the lining membrane of the mouth; then burning and often
constriction in the throat and gullet, with difficult and painful
deglutition; violent vomiting, often sanguinolent, and tinging vegetable
blues green; next acute pain in the stomach and tenderness of the whole
belly; subsequently cold sweats, excessive weakness, hiccup, tremors and
twitches of the extremities; and ere long violent colic pains, with
purging of bloody stools and dark membranous flakes. So far the symptoms
are nearly the same in all cases; but in their subsequent course several
varieties may be noticed.
In the worst form of poisoning death ensues at an early period, for
example within twenty-four hours, nay even before time enough has
elapsed for diarrhœa to begin. A case of this kind, which has been very
well described by Mr. Dewar of Dunfermline, and which arose from the
patient, a boy, having accidentally swallowed about three ounces of a
strong solution of carbonate of potass, proved fatal in twelve hours
only.[438] Here death was owing to the general system or some vital
organ being affected through sympathy by the injury sustained by the
alimentary canal.
In the mildest form, as in a case related by Plenck[439] of a man who
swallowed an ounce of the carbonate of potass, the symptoms represent
pretty nearly an attack of acute gastritis when followed by
recovery,—the effects on man being then analogous to those observed by
Bretonneau in animals, when the poison was introduced into the stomach
without touching the gullet.
But a more common form than either of the preceding is one, similar to
the chronic form of poisoning with the mineral acids, in which constant
vomiting of food and drink, incessant discharge of fluid, sanguinolent
stools, difficulty of swallowing, burning pain from the mouth to the
anus, and rapid emaciation, continue for weeks or even months before the
patient’s strength is exhausted; and where death is evidently owing to
starvation, the alimentary canal being no longer capable of assimilating
food. Two characteristic examples of this singular affection have been
recorded in the Medical Repository,[440] and a third, of which the event
has not been mentioned, but which would in all likelihood end fatally,
has been communicated by M. Jules Cloquet to Orfila.[441] Of the two
first cases, which were caused by half an ounce of carbonate of potass
having been taken in solution by mistake for a laxative salt, one proved
fatal in little more than a month, the other three weeks afterwards. In
Cloquet’s case, at the end of the sixth week the membrane of the mouth
was regenerated; but the gullet continued to discharge pus, and the
stools were purulent and bloody.
Another form perhaps equally common with that just described, and not
less certainly fatal, commences like the rest with violent symptoms of
irritation in the mouth, gullet, and stomach; but the bowels are not
affected, and by and by it becomes apparent that the stomach is little
injured; dysphagia or even complete inability to swallow, burning pain
and constriction in the gullet, hawking and coughing of tough, leathery
flakes, are then the leading symptoms; at length the case becomes one of
stricture of the œsophagus with or without ulceration; the bougie gives
only temporary relief, and the patient eventually expires either of mere
starvation, or of that combined with an exhausting fever. Mr. Dewar has
related a very striking example of this form of poisoning with the
alkalis.[442] His patient, after the first violent symptoms had
exhausted themselves, which took place in sixteen or eighteen hours,
suffered little for four or five days till the sloughs began to separate
from the lining membrane of the mouth, throat, and gullet. The affection
of the gullet then became gradually predominant, and terminated in
stricture, of which she appears to have been several times so much
relieved as to have been thought in a fair way of recovery. After
repeatedly disappointing Mr. Dewar’s hopes of a successful issue by her
intemperance in the use of spirituous liquors, she died of starvation
about four months after swallowing the poison. Sir Charles Bell has
noticed three parallel cases, and has given delineations of the
appearance in the gullet of two of them.[443] One of his patients did
not die till twenty years after swallowing the poison, which in this
instance was soap-less; yet he does not hesitate to ascribe the
stricture to that cause, and says death arose purely from starvation.
The carbonate of soda, though a salt in very common use, has not
hitherto been the cause of accident, which has found its way into print.
It is plainly much less actively corrosive than carbonate of potass, and
is therefore probably in every sense less energetic.
SECTION III.—_Of the Morbid Appearances caused by the fixed Alkalis._
The morbid appearances caused by potass, soda, and their carbonates
differ with the nature of the case.
In the boy who died in twelve hours Mr. Dewar found the inner membrane
of the throat and gullet almost entirely disorganized and reduced to a
pulp, with blood extravasated between it and the muscular coat. The
inner coat of the stomach was red, in two round patches destroyed, and
the patches covered with a clot of blood;—its outer coat, as well as all
the other abdominal viscera, was sound.
In the two chronic cases mentioned in the Medical Repository the
mischief was much more general, the whole peritonæum being condensed,
the omentum dark and turgid, the intestines glued together by lymph, the
external coats of the stomach thick, the villous coat almost all
destroyed, what remained of it red and near the pylorus ulcerated, and
the pyloric orifice of the stomach plugged up with lymph so as barely to
admit a small probe.
In Mr. Dewar’s patient who died of stricture of the gullet the
intestines were sound, the inner surface of the stomach red especially
towards the cardia, the inner and muscular coats of the gullet thickened
and firmly incorporated together by effused lymph, the inner coat here
and there wanting, the passage of the gullet every where contracted, and
to such a degree about two inches above the cardia as hardly to pass a
common probe. In Sir C. Bell’s cases the appearances were similar.
Orfila says he is led to conclude from a great number of facts that of
all corrosive poisons potass is the one which most frequently perforates
the stomach.[444] This appearance, however, has not been mentioned in
any case of poisoning in the human subject.
SECTION IV.—_Of the Treatment of Poisoning with the fixed Alkalis._
In the treatment of poisoning with the alkalis the first object is
evidently to neutralize the poison. This may be done either with a weak
acid, or with oil. Of the acids the acetic in the form of vinegar is
most generally recommended, as it is not itself injurious. A successful
case in very unpromising circumstances, where two ounces and a half of
carbonate of potash had been taken by mistake for cream of tartar, and
where the antidote was not administered for half an hour, has been
related by M. Liégard of Caen. Great relief was experienced to the
burning in the throat and stomach, the chilliness, difficult breathing,
and frequent efforts to vomit, which were the first symptoms; and after
repeated alternations of collapse and reaction, convalescence was
established in eight days.[445]—M. Chereau thinks that for the mineral
alkalis and their carbonates fixed oil is a preferable antidote to
vinegar; and he has given the heads of two cases of poisoning with large
doses of carbonate of potass, in which the free employment of almond oil
prevented the usual fatal consequences. It appears to act partly by
rendering the vomiting free and easy, partly by converting the alkali
into a soap. It must be given in large quantity, several pounds being
commonly required.[446] For the subsequent treatment the reader may
consult the paper of Mr. Dewar, which contains many useful hints on the
management of the most complex description of cases.
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter