Treatise on Poisons by Sir Robert Christison
introduction of lead into the system. Dr. Burton thinks it will when the
3672 words | Chapter 152
blue line at the edge of the gums is seen.
The work of Mérat contains some interesting numerical documents,
illustrative of the trades which expose artisans to colica pictonum.
They are derived from the lists kept at the hospital of La Charité in
Paris, during the years 1776 and 1811. The total number of cases of
colica pictonum in both years was 279. Of these, 241 were artisans whose
trades exposed them to the poison of lead, namely, 148 painters, 28
plumbers, 16 potters, 15 porcelain-makers, 12 lapidaries, 9
colour-grinders, 3 glass-blowers, 2 glaziers, 2 toy-men, 2 shoemakers, a
printer, a lead-miner, a leaf-beater, a shot-manufacturer. Of the
remainder, 17 belonged to trades in which they were exposed to copper,
namely, 7 button-makers, 5 brass-founders, 4 braziers, and a
copper-turner. The remaining twenty-one were tradesmen, who worked
little, or not at all with either metal, namely, 4 varnishers, 2
gilders, 2 locksmiths, a hatter, a saltpetre-maker, a winegrocer, a
vine-dresser, a labourer, a distiller, a stone-cutter, a calciner,[1352]
a soldier, a house-servant, a waiter, and an attorney’s clerk.—Age or
youth seems not to afford any protection against the poison. Of the 279
cases, 24 were under twenty, and among these were several painter-boys
not above fifteen years old; 113 were between nineteen and thirty; 66
between twenty-nine and forty; 38 between thirty-nine and fifty; 28
between forty-nine and sixty; and 10 older than sixty. These proportions
correspond pretty nearly with the relative number of workmen of similar
ages.—Among the 279 cases fifteen died, or 5·4 per cent.
There seems to have lately been little or no diminution in the frequency
of the disease in Paris. In 1833–4–5–6, there were treated in the
hospitals 1541 cases, or 385 annually; of whom one in 39½ died. And in
1839–40–41 there were 761 cases, or 252 annually; of whom one in 24½
died. Of 302 cases in 1841 no fewer then 266 were from white-lead
manufactories.[1353]
SECTION III.—_Of the Morbid Appearances caused by Lead._
The morbid appearances caused by poisoning with lead are in some
respects peculiar.
In acute poisoning, from the irritant action of its soluble salts, as in
the case of the drummer poisoned by Goulard’s extract, the lower end of
the gullet, the whole stomach and duodenum, part of the jejunum, and the
ascending and transverse colon, have been found much inflamed, and the
villous coat of the stomach as if macerated. In Mr. Taylor’s two cases
Dr. Bird found the villous coat of the stomach gray, but otherwise
natural; and the intestines were much contracted.
The stomach in the first of these cases contained a reddish-brown,
sweetish, styptic fluid, in which lead was detected by chemical
analysis,[1354]—an important medico-legal fact, since the man survived
nearly three days. Some valuable observations have been made by
Professor Orfila as to the presence of lead in the textures of the
stomach in such instances. When small doses of acetate or nitrate of
lead were administered to dogs and allowed to act for two hours only,
the villous coat presented numerous streaks of white points, which
contained lead, as hydrosulphuric acid blackened them. These points,
though less distinct, were still visible, when the animals were allowed
to live four days after the excess of salt had been removed; and even
after seventeen days, although no such appearance remained, lead could
still be detected in the tissues of the stomach.[1355]
The blood in animals is sometimes altered. Dr. Campbell found it fluid.
In a dog poisoned with litharge, the experimentalists of the Veterinary
School at Lyons found it of a vermilion colour in the veins, and
brighter than usual in the arteries.[1356] Mitscherlich also found it
unusually red and firmly coagulated.[1357]
The appearances in the bodies of those who have died of the various
forms of lead colic are different, and wholly unconnected with
inflammation.
The valuable work of Mérat contains four inspections after death from
the acute or comatose form of colica pictonum. The bodies were plump,
muscular and fat. The alimentary canal was quite empty, and the colon
much contracted,—in one to an extraordinary degree. The mucous coat of
the alimentary canal was everywhere healthy. He therefore infers that
the disease is an affection of the muscular coat only. It is a striking
circumstance, and conformable with what will be afterwards established
in regard to the true narcotics, that although both of the men died
convulsed and comatose, no morbid appearance was visible within the
head.[1358] Another case, which confirms the foregoing facts, has been
described by Mr. Deering. It was that of a lady who died convulsed after
suffering in the usual manner, and in whose body no trace of disease
could be detected any where.[1359] Senac informed Tronchin that he had
dissected above fifty cases of colica pictonum, and found no morbid
appearances.[1360] Schloepfer’s observations on animals are to the same
effect. In rabbits which died of colica pictonum the great intestines
were excessively contracted, but all the other organs of the body were
healthy except the liver, which was dark and brittle.[1361] Mitscherlich
observed in his animals extravasation of blood into the intestines, also
sometimes into the cavities of the pleura and peritoneum, and
occasionally under the peritoneal covering of the kidneys.[1362] The
only instance I have met with where morbid appearances were found within
the head, was in a case mentioned by Sir G. Baker, of a gentleman who
died apoplectic after many attacks of colica pictonum, and in whom the
brain was found unusually soft, and blood extravasated on its surface to
the amount of an ounce.[1363]
The appearances in those who have been long affected with the paralytic
form of colica pictonum have been rarely observed in modern times. I am
indebted to my late colleague, Dr. Duncan, Junior, for an account of the
appearances in the intestinal canal of a plumber, who had been long and
frequently afflicted with colica pictonum and its sequelæ. The
intestines were dark, tender, and far advanced in putrefaction. The
cardiac orifice of the stomach was so narrow that it would admit a
goose-quill. The mesenteric glands were enlarged and hardened. The
thoracic duct was surrounded by many large bodies like diseased glands,
exactly of the colour of lead, and composed of organized cysts
containing apparently an inorganic matter. The analysis of this matter
was unfortunately neglected. The muscles in similar circumstances are
much diseased. When the paralysis is not of long standing, it appears
from the experiments of Schloepfer (whose animals survived about three
weeks), that the whole muscular system becomes pale, bloodless, and
flaccid. When the palsy is of long standing, this change increases so
much, that the muscles in some parts, as in the arms and thumbs, acquire
the colour and general aspect of white fibrous tissue. Some observations
on the nature of these changes will be found in the essays of Sir G.
Baker.[1364] The facts are communicated by Mr. John Hunter. On examining
the muscles of the arm and hand of a house-painter who was killed by an
accident, Mr. Hunter found them all of a cream colour, and very opaque,
their fibres distinct, and their texture unusually dry and tough. These
alterations he at first imagined might have been the result merely of
the palsy and consequent inactivity of the muscles, but on finding the
same alterations produced by the direct action of sugar of lead on
muscle, he inferred that the poison gradually effected a change either
on the muscles directly, or on the blood which supplied them.
In a late elaborate inquiry into the pathology of lead-colic, M.
Tanquerel has arrived at the conclusion, that “the pathological
phenomena are not caused by anatomical changes cognisable by the
senses,” and that such appearances as may be found are the effects, not
the cause, of the disease.[1365]
SECTION IV.—_Of the Treatment of Poisoning with Lead._
The treatment of poisoning with lead, and the mode of protecting workmen
from its influence, will now require a few remarks.
For the irritant form of poisoning, a safe and effectual antidote exists
in any of the soluble alkaline or earthy sulphates. If none of these be
at hand, then the alkaline carbonates may be given, particularly the
bicarbonates, which are not so irritating as the carbonates. The
phosphate of soda is also an excellent antidote. If the patient does not
vomit, it will be right also to give an emetic of the sulphate of zinc.
In other respects, the treatment does not differ from that of poisoning
with the irritants generally.
Colica pictonum is usually treated in this country with great success by
a practice much followed here in colic and diarrhœa of all kinds,—the
conjunction of purgatives with anodynes. A full dose of a neutral
laxative salt is given, and an hour afterwards a full dose of opium.
Sometimes alvine discharges take place before the opium acts, more
commonly not till its action is past, and occasionally not for a
considerable time afterwards. But the pain and vomiting subside, the
restlessness and irritability pass away, and the bowels return nearly or
entirely to their natural condition. Sometimes it is necessary to repeat
the practice. It is almost always successful. I have seldom seen the
second dose fail to remove the colic, leaving the bowels at worst in a
state of constipation. Dr. Alderson of Hull, who has had many
opportunities of treating the workmen of a white-lead manufactory there,
says powerful purgatives, such as croton-oil, are highly serviceable in
severe cases, and are borne well notwithstanding the extreme debility
often present.[1366] M. Tanquerel says he has found this treatment more
effectual in Paris than any other means.[1367] When the pulse is full
and strong, I have seen venesection premised with apparent advantage; in
some instances it appeared to me to be called for by the flushing of the
face and the violence of the spasms; and I have never seen it otherwise
than a safe remedy, notwithstanding the fears expressed by Dr. Warren
and others.[1368]
The hospital of La Charité in Paris has long enjoyed a high reputation
for the treatment of this disease. In the first place a decoction is
given of half an ounce of senna in a pound of water, mixed with half an
ounce of sulphate of magnesia and four ounces of the wine of antimony.
Next day an ounce of sulphate of magnesia and three grains of
tartar-emetic are administered in two pounds of infusion of cassia, to
keep up the operation of the first laxative. In the evening a clyster is
given, containing twelve ounces of wine and half as much oil. After this
the patient is made to vomit with tartar-emetic, then drenched with
_ptisanes_ for several days, and the treatment is wound up with another
dose of the first purgative succeeded by gentle anodynes. I am not aware
of any particular advantage possessed by this complicated and tormenting
method of cure, which is not equally possessed by the simpler plan
pursued in Britain.
In 1831 M. Gendrin announced to the French Institute that he had found
sulphuric acid to be at once the most effectual remedy, and the most
certain preventive, for the injurious effects of lead; and he has
subsequently spoken in strong terms of the utility of this
treatment.[1369] But the experience of others does not bear out his
conclusions.[1370]
Among the many other methods of cure that have been proposed for the
primary stage of this disease, salivation by mercury deserves to be
particularized. It appears to have been often used with success, the
colic yielding as soon as ptyalism sets in.[1371] If the case, however,
is severe, there is no time to lose in waiting for the action of the
mercury to commence.
The treatment in the advanced period of the disease, when palsy is the
chief symptom remaining, depends almost entirely on regimen. The patient
must for a time at least quit altogether his unlucky trade. He should be
allowed the most generous food he can digest. He ought to take frequent
gentle exercise in the open air, but never to fatigue. The hands being
the most severely injured of the affected parts, and at the same time
the most important to the workman, the practitioner’s attention should
be directed peculiarly to the restoration of their muscular power. This
appears to be most easily brought about by frictions, electricity, and
regulated exercise, the hands being also supported in the intervals by
splints extending from the elbows to the fingers. The dragging of the
emaciated muscles by the weight of the dangling hands certainly seems to
retard recovery.—Strychnia has also been repeatedly found of service in
restoring muscular action. Tanquerel states that electricity and
strychnia, but especially the latter, have appeared to him by far the
most efficacious remedies both for muscular paralysis and for
amaurosis.—In the head affections the best treatment consists in relying
on nature and merely combating symptoms; and blood-letting is of no use,
however much it may seem to be indicated by the coma and convulsions.
When a person has been once attacked with colica pictonum, he is more
easily attacked again. Hence if he is young enough, he should, if
possible, change his profession for one in which he is not brought into
proximity with lead. Few, however, have it in their power to do so. The
prophylaxis, therefore, or mode of preventing the influence of the
poison, becomes a subject of great importance; and more particularly
when we consider the vast number of workmen in different trades, whose
safety it is intended to secure.
On this subject many useful instructions are laid down in the work of
Mérat. He very properly sets out with insisting on the utmost regard
being paid to cleanliness,—a point too much neglected by most artizans,
and particularly by those to whom it is most necessary, the artizans who
work with the metals. In proof of the importance of this rule, he
observes he knew a potter, who contracted the lead colic early in life
when he was accustomed to go about very dirty, but for thirty years
after had not any return of it, in consequence simply of a scrupulous
attention to cleanliness. In order to secure due cleanliness three
points should be attended to. In the first place, the face and hands
should be washed once a day at least, the mouth well rinsed, and the
hair occasionally combed. Secondly, frequent bathing is of great
consequence, both with a view to cleanliness and as a general tonic; so
that masters should provide their workmen with sufficient means and
opportunities for practising it. Lastly, the working clothes should be
made, not of woollen, but of strong, compact linen, should be changed
and washed at least once and still better twice a week, and should be
worn as little as possible out of the workshop. While at work a cap of
some light impervious material should always be worn.
Next to cleanliness, the most important article of the prophylaxis
relates to the means for preventing the food being impregnated with
lead. For this end it is essential that the workmen never take their
meals in the workshop, and that before eating they wash their lips and
hands with soap and water, and brush out all particles of dirt from the
nails. It is also of moment that they breakfast before going to work in
the morning.
Derangements of the digestive organs should be watched with great care.
If they appear to arise from the poison of lead, the individual should
leave off work with the very first symptom, and take a laxative.
Habitual constipation should be provided against.
The nature of the diet of the workmen is of some consequence. It should
be as far as possible of a nutritive and digestible kind. Mérat condemns
in strong terms the small tart wines generally used by the lower ranks
of his countrymen. They constitute a very poor drink for all artizans;
and are peculiarly ill adapted for those who work with lead, because,
besides being at times themselves adulterated with that poison, they are
also apt to disorder the bowels by their acidity. Beer is infinitely
preferable. Various articles of diet have been recommended as tending to
impede the operation of the poison. Hoffmann recommends brandy, the
efficacy of which few workmen will dispute. There is some reason for
believing that the free use of fat and fatty articles of food is a
preservative. Dehaen was informed by the proprietor and the physician of
a lead mine in Styria, that the work-people were once very liable to
colic and palsy, but that, after being told by a quack doctor to eat a
good deal of fat, especially at breakfast, they were exempt for three
years.[1372] Another fact of the kind was communicated to Sir George
Baker by a physician at Osterhoüt, near Breda. The village contained a
great number of potters, among whom he did not witness a single case of
lead colic in the course of fifteen years; and he attributes their
immunity to their having lived much on cheese, butter, bacon, and other
fatty kinds of food.[1373] Mr. Wilson says, in his account of the colic
at Leadhills in Lanarkshire, that English workmen, who live much on fat
meat, suffer less than Scotchmen, who do not.[1374]
Professor Liebig says that lead colic is unknown in all white-lead
manufactories, where the workmen use as a beverage lemonade or
sugar-water acidulated with sulphuric acid; and it was stated above that
the same announcement has been made by Mr. Gendrin. This, however, is
doubtful. The prophylactic effects of sulphuric acid have been denied in
France by M. Tanquerel,[1375] and M. Grisolle;[1376] the latter of whom
in particular says that no advantage whatever was derived from it at the
white-lead manufactory of Clichy near Paris.
Some have likewise proposed as an additional preservative, that the
exposed parts of the body should be anointed with oily or fatty matters.
But Mérat maintains with some reason, that the lead will be thereby
enabled to penetrate the cuticle more easily by friction and pressure.
The observance of the preceding rules will depend of course in a great
measure on the intelligence and docility of the workmen. It would appear
that particular care should be taken in hot weather, statistical facts
having shown that three times as many workmen are attacked in Paris
during the month of January as in July.[1377]
Some other objects of much consequence are to be attained by the
humanity and skill of the masters.
The workshop should be spacious, and both thoroughly and systematically
ventilated, the external air being freely admitted when the weather will
allow, and particular currents being established, by which floating
particles are carried away in certain invariable and known courses.
Miners and others who work at furnaces in which lead is smelted, fused,
or oxidated, should be protected by a strong draught through the
furnaces. According to Mr. Braid, wherever furnaces of such a
construction were built at Leadhills, the colic disappeared; while it
continued to recur where the furnaces were of the old, low-chimneyed
form. Manufacturers of litharge and red-lead used formerly to suffer
much in consequence of the furnaces being so constructed as to compel
them to inhale the fine dust of the oxides. In drawing the furnaces the
hot material is raked out upon the floor, which is two or three feet
below the aperture in the furnace; and the finer particles are therefore
driven up and diffused through the apartment. But this obvious danger is
now completely averted by a subsidiary chimney, which rises in front of
the drawing aperture, and through which a strong current of air is
attracted from the apartment, the hot material on the ground performing
the part of a fire.
In white-lead manufactories a very important and simple improvement has
been effected of late in some places by abandoning the practice of
dry-grinding. In all manufactories of the kind, the ultimate pulverizing
of the white lead has been long performed under water. But in general
the preparatory process of rolling, by which the carbonate is separated
from the sheets of lead on which it is formed, continues to be executed
dry. This is a very dangerous operation, because the workmen must inhale
a great deal of the fine dust of the carbonate. In a white-lead
manufactory which formerly existed at Portobello, the process was
entirely performed under water or with damping; and to this precaution
in a great measure was imputed the improvement effected by the
proprietor in the health of the workmen, and their superior immunity
from disease over those of Hull and other places, where the same
precaution was not taken at that time. The only operation latterly
considered dangerous at the Portobello works was the emptying of the
drying stove, and the packing of the white lead in barrels; and the dust
diffused in that process was kept down as much as possible by the floor
being maintained constantly damp. By these precautions, by making the
workmen wash their hands and faces before leaving the works for their
meals, and by administering a brisk dose of castor oil on the first
appearance of any complaint of the stomach or bowels, the manufacturer
succeeded in extirpating colica pictonum entirely for several
years.—This trade continues to be a very pernicious one in France; for
no fewer than 266 cases of colic were admitted into the Parisian
hospitals in 1841 from the white-lead manufactories in and near the
capital. Yet facts are not wanting there to prove that with proper care
the disease may be all but extirpated. A French manufacturer, whose
workmen at one time suffered severely, had no case of colic among them
for nine years after breaking them in to the observance of due
precautions.[1378] Another says, from his own experience and information
obtained at other works, he is satisfied the risk is very much greater
among the intemperate than among sober workmen.[1379]
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter