Treatise on Poisons by Sir Robert Christison
5. Somewhat analogous to the symptoms now described are the effects of
2239 words | Chapter 188
the gradual contamination of air in a confined apartment. Every one must
have read of the horrible death of the Englishmen who were locked up all
night in a close dungeon in Fort William at Calcutta. One hundred and
forty-six individuals were imprisoned in a room twenty feet square, with
only one small window; and before next morning all but 23 died under the
most dreadful of tortures,—that of slowly increasing suffocation. They
seem to have been affected nearly in the same way as the workmen at
Leadhills.[2094] A similar accident happened in London in 1742. The
keeper of the round-house of St. Martin’s, crammed 28 people into an
apartment six feet square and not quite six feet high; and four were
suffocated.[2095]
The morbid appearances left on the body after poisoning with carbonic
acid gas have been chiefly observed in persons killed by charcoal
vapour. According to Portal the vessels of the brain are congested, and
the ventricles contain serum; the lungs are distended, as if
emphysematous; the heart and great veins are gorged with black fluid
blood; the eyes are generally glistening and prominent, the face red,
and the tongue protruded and black.[2096]—Gorging of the cerebral
vessels seems to be very common. Yet sometimes it is inconsiderable, as
in two cases related by Dr. Bright, where, except in the sinuses and in
the greater veins of the ventricles and substance of the brain, no
particular gorging or vascularity seems to have been met with,—the
external membranes in particular having been very little injected.[2097]
This, however, is certainly a rare occurrence. Serous effusion in the
ventricles and under the arachnoid membrane is very general, yet not
invariable.—Dr. Schenck, medical inspector of Siegen, in reporting two
cases of death caused by the vapours of burning wood, notices paleness
of the countenance as a singular accompaniment of cerebral congestion;
and calls the attention of medical jurists to the extreme calmness of
the features as a general character of this variety of poisoning.[2098]
Although the same appearance has also been noticed by others,[2099] the
countenance nevertheless is often livid. But whether livid or pale, it
is always composed.—It appears from an account in Pyl’s Essays of
several cases of suffocation from the fumes of burning wood, that
besides the appearances mentioned by Portal, there is usually great
livor of the back, frothiness as well as fluidity of the blood, and more
or less gorging of the lungs with blood.[2100]—A common appearance where
the poisonous emanation has been charcoal vapour, is a lining of dark,
or sometimes actually black dust on the mucous membranes of the air
passages, thickest near the external opening of the nostrils, and
disappearing towards the glottis. There are obvious reasons why this
appearance cannot always be expected to occur; but when present, it may
be in doubtful circumstances a very important article of evidence.[2101]
In Wildberg’s collection of cases there is a report on two people who
were suffocated in bed, in consequence of the servant having neglected
to open the flue-trap when she kindled the stove in the bed-chamber; and
in each of them Wildberg found all the appearances now quoted from
Portal and Pyl. The tongue was black and swelled.[2102]—Mertzdorff has
related a case of death from the same cause, in which, together with the
preceding appearances, an effusion of blood was found between
the arachnoid and pia mater over the whole surface of both
hemispheres.[2103] In one of Dr. Bright’s cases there was a small
ecchymosis in the cortical substance on the outer side of the anterior
lobe, and not extending into the medullary matter. Fallot mentions an
instance of suffocation from charcoal vapour, where a little coagulated
blood was found between the layers of the arachnoid membrane of the
cerebellum in the region of the left occipital hollow.[2104] Three
instances of extravasation are enumerated in a list of German cases
analysed by Dr. Bird.[2105] Such appearances might be expected more
frequently, considering the manifest tendency of this kind of poisoning
to cause congestion in the head.—The blood is generally described as
being liquid and very dark. But M. Ollivier has lately called attention
to the fact, that the blood both before and after death is not unusually
more florid in the veins than natural.[2106] In a case mentioned by M.
Rayer globules of an oily-looking matter were found swimming on the
surface of the blood and urine.[2107] This is a solitary
observation.—The body usually remains flaccid, and the customary stage
of rigidity is imperfect. In some instances, however, as in those
related by Dr. Schenck, the stage of rigidity is passed through in the
usual manner. It is not uncommon to find vomited matter lying beside the
body, a circumstance which may naturally mislead the unpractised. This
is represented by Professor Wagner of Berlin to have occurred uniformly
in his experience;[2108] and it is also mentioned in many of the cases
reported by others;[2109] but it is not invariable.—A red appearance in
the stomach and intestines has been noticed in many cases,[2110] and
often ascribed to inflammation; but it is probably nothing more than the
result of the venous congestion, which pervades most of the membranous
surfaces of the body.
The least variable appearances according to Dr. Bird are general
lividity, protrusion of the tongue, a calm expression and attitude,
cerebral congestion, and serous effusion. This author’s paper in the
Medical Gazette, 1838–39, i., or in Guy’s Hospital Reports, iv., enters
very fully into the appearances after death, and may be consulted with
advantage for further details.
The treatment of poisoning with carbonic acid consists chiefly in the
occasional employment of the cold affusion, and in moderate
blood-letting either from the arm or from the head. In a case which
happened at Paris, where a lady tried to make away with herself by
breathing charcoal fumes, and was found in a state of almost hopeless
insensibility, various remedies were tried unsuccessfully, till cupping
from the nape of the neck was resorted to; and she then rapidly
recovered.[2111] Another instance where blood-letting was also
singularly successful deserves particular mention; because for three
hours the patient remained without pulsation in any artery, and without
the slightest perceptible respiration. At first neither by cupping nor
by venesection could any blood be obtained; and it was only after the
long interval just mentioned, and constant artificial inflation of the
lungs, that the blood at length trickled slowly from the arm. The pulse
and breathing were after this soon re-established; but it was not till
eight hours later that sensibility returned.[2112]
_Of Poisoning with Carbonic Oxide Gas._—Carbonic oxide gas, according to
Nysten, has not any effect on man when injected into the pleura; but
when thrown slowly into the veins, it gives the arterial blood a
brownish tint, and induces for a short time a state resembling
intoxication.[2113] The quantity injected into the veins was probably
too small to produce the full effect, or it was discharged in passing
through the lungs; for this gas certainly appears to be very deleterious
when breathed by man, or the lower animals. M. Leblanc found by
experiment that a sparrow was killed almost immediately in air
containing only a twentieth of it, and that so little even as a
hundredth part proved fatal in two minutes.[2114]
A set of interesting but hazardous experiments were made with it in 1814
by the assistants of Mr. Higgins of Dublin. One gentleman, after
inhaling it two or three times, was seized with giddiness, tremors, and
an approach to insensibility, succeeded by languor, weakness, and
headache of some hours’ duration. The other had almost paid dearly for
his curiosity. Having previously exhausted his lungs, he inhaled the
pure gas three or four times, upon which he was suddenly deprived of
sense and motion, fell down supine, and continued for half an hour
insensible, apparently lifeless, and with the pulse nearly extinct.
Various means were tried for rousing him, without success; till at last
oxygen gas was blown into the lungs. Animation then returned rapidly:
but he was affected for the rest of the day with convulsive agitation of
the body, stupor, violent headache, and quick irregular pulse; and after
his senses were quite restored, he suffered from giddiness, blindness,
nausea, alternate heats and chills, and then feverish, broken, but
irresistible sleep.[2115] A French aëronaut, who used for his balloon a
mixture of carbonic oxide and hydrogen, obtained by decomposing water
with red-hot charcoal, lately suffered from similar symptoms in a milder
degree, in consequence of the gas being disengaged upon him from the
safety-valve of his balloon.[2116]
_Of Poisoning with Nitrous Oxide Gas._—The nitrous oxide or intoxicating
gas is the last of the narcotic gases to be noticed. Nysten found, that,
when slowly injected in large quantity into the veins of animals, it
only caused slight staggering.[2117] Frequent observation, however, has
shown that it is by no means so inert when breathed by man. Sir H. Davy,
who first had the courage to inhale it, observed that it excited
giddiness, a delightful sense of thrilling in the chest and limbs,
acuteness of hearing, brilliancy of all surrounding objects, and an
unconquerable propensity to brisk muscular exertion. These feelings were
of short duration, but were generally succeeded by alertness of body and
mind, never by the exhaustion, depression, and nausea, which follow the
stage of excitement brought on by spirits or opium.[2118] Although many
have since experienced the same enticing effects, yet they are by no
means uniform. For others have been suddenly seized with great weakness,
tendency to faint, loss of voice, and sometimes convulsions; and two of
Thenard’s assistants, on making the experiment, fainted away, and
remained some seconds motionless and insensible.[2119] It is a
remarkable circumstance in the operation of this gas, that, unlike other
stimulants, it does not lose its virtues under the influence of habit.
Neither does the habitual use of it lead to any ill consequence. Sir H.
Davy, in the course of his researches, which were continued above two
months, breathed it occasionally three or four times a day for a week
together, at other periods four or five times a week only; yet at the
end his health was good, his mind clear, his digestion perfect, and his
strength only a little impaired.[2120]
Nitrous oxide gas is one of the few gases that are not injurious to
vegetables. Dr. Turner and I found that seventy-two cubic inches,
diluted with six times their volume of air, had no effect on a
mignionette plant in forty-eight hours.[2121]
_Of Poisoning with Cyanogen Gas._—_Cyanogen gas_ has been proved by the
experiments of M. Coullon to be an active poison to all animals,—the
guinea-pig, sparrow, leech, frog, wood-louse, fly, crab; and the
symptoms induced were coma, and more rarely convulsions.[2122] These
results are confirmed by the later experiments of Hünefeld, who found
that it produces in the rabbit anxious breathing, slight convulsions,
staring of the eyes, dilated pupils, coma, and death in five or six
minutes.[2123] Buchner likewise found that small birds, held for a few
seconds over the mouth of a jar containing cyanogen, died very speedily;
and on one occasion remarked, while preparing the gas, that the
fore-finger, which was exposed to the bubbles as they escaped, became
suddenly benumbed, and that this effect was attended with a singular
feeling of pressure and contraction in the joints of the thumb and
elbow.[2124] It would undoubtedly be most dangerous to breathe this gas,
except much diluted, and in very small quantity.
Of all narcotic gases it is the most noxious to vegetables. Dr. Turner
and I found that a third of a cubic inch, diluted with 1700 times its
volume of air, caused the leaves of a mignionette plant to droop in
twenty-four hours. As usual with the effects of narcotic gases on
vegetables, the drooping went on after the plant was removed into the
open air; and in a short time it was completely killed.[2125]
_Of Poisoning with Oxygen Gas._—Of all the narcotic gases, none is
more singular in its effects than oxygen. When breathed in a state of
purity by animals, they live much longer than in the same volume of
atmospheric air. But if the experiment be kept up for a sufficient
length of time, symptoms of narcotic poisoning begin to manifest
themselves. For an hour no inconvenience seems to be felt; but the
breathing and pulse then become accelerated; a state of debility next
ensues; at length insensibility gradually comes on, with glazing of
the eyes, slow respiration and gasping; coma is in the end completely
formed; and death ensues in the course of six, ten, or twelve hours.
If the animals are removed into the air before the insensibility is
considerable, they quickly recover. When the body is examined
immediately after death, the heart is seen beating strongly, but the
diaphragm motionless; the whole blood in the veins as well as the
arteries is of a bright scarlet colour; some of the membranous
surfaces, such as the pulmonary pleura, have the same tint, and the
blood coagulates with remarkable rapidity. The gas in which an animal
has died rekindles a blown out taper. These experiments, which
physiology owes to the researches of Mr. Broughton,[2126] furnish a
solitary example of death from stoppage of the respiration, although
the heart continues to pulsate, and the lungs to transmit florid
blood. Death is probably owing to hyper-arterialization of the blood.
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter