Accounting theory and practice, Volume 2 (of 3) : a textbook for colleges and…
CHAPTER XXIII
849 words | Chapter 123
SURPLUS AND RESERVES
Definition
Under the corporate form of organization, “surplus” in its broadest
sense represents the difference between the net worth of the business
and the capital stock issued and outstanding. Because of the legal
requirement that the value of the capital stock be shown always at
the original amount—which is usually par—any increments or decrements
in value because of profits or losses made and reinvested in the
enterprise must be shown under separate heads. Thus surplus—or
deficit—is the general term to indicate this increase in value. In
England the term “rest” is used in almost this same sense. “Margin” is
also a title occasionally seen.
Because of a much narrower technical meaning given to surplus, the
general adoption of another term with the broader connotation above
given would serve a really useful purpose. Of the titles in use, margin
seems best to express the exact shade of meaning. In the interest of a
standard terminology, the highest accounting authorities are coming to
restrict surplus to that portion of the margin available for dividends
and in that sense the word will be used in this chapter. Contrary uses
of the word are frequently met. In banking institutions the surplus is
almost as inviolable as the capital stock itself and is never used for
dividend purposes. In government-controlled or supervised institutions,
these special uses of the term have become too well established by
law and custom ever to hope for a change in the interest of general
uniformity.
Creation of Margin
The sources of the margin have for the most part been already
indicated. The chief source is the net profit for the period as
determined by the Profit and Loss account balance. What enters into
that balance has been discussed in Chapter XXII, where it was also
pointed out that under some circumstances it may be entirely legitimate
to carry some temporary proprietorship items directly to a vested
proprietorship account instead of by way of the summary account. Thus
there may be other sources of margin than the current balance of Profit
and Loss—extraordinary items whose inclusion with current summaries of
operation would render those summaries useless as a guide for judging
comparative results of various periods.
_Capital Stock Premiums._ Sometimes, for the purpose of creating a
margin at the inception of an enterprise a fund is contributed beyond
the par value of the capital stock issued. This is accomplished by
purchase of the stock at a premium, and is frequently seen in banking
institutions, where it serves as an easy and speedy way to satisfy the
law’s requirements for the accumulation of a “surplus.” The effect
of this is to give the institution a better standing than it would
otherwise have. The reduction of the capital stock outstanding without
full recompense to the stockholder also results in the creation of
margin. This is often done in reorganizations when fewer shares of the
new stock are given than were held of the old. The effect, then, is to
set up a book profit against which may be charged the existing deficit,
and so secure a balance between the real net worth and the par of the
new stock issue.
_Stock Donation._ Another source of margin is a stock donation. This
may result in only a book profit. It is exceedingly difficult and
generally impossible to determine the true value of many speculative
ventures, such as mining enterprises. As a general rule, capitalization
based on opinion is usually overcapitalization. While a stock donation
may have no relation to real values and is merely a method of securing
working capital, its effect when the stock is sold is to increase the
cash asset and show a profit of an equal amount. Some authorities hold
that instead of retaining the profit on the books, the logical thing
is to reduce the carrying values of the speculative assets by the
amount of the realized profit on stock donation. There would be more
reason for this treatment were there any real relationship between the
amount of the stock donation and the overvaluation of the assets. Since
usually there is none and the whole undertaking is speculative, there
is no valid objection to showing the realized profit, as the public is
sufficiently warned by the nature of the enterprise. All stock donation
is not of this sort, however. Occasionally a very real profit results
which should be treated as a margin item.
_Stock Assessments, etc._ Similar to a stock donation is a stock
assessment. In cases of reorganization or of impending bankruptcy,
a pro rata assessment is levied on the outstanding shares. Being a
donation, it constitutes a proprietorship increase item and becomes
a part of the margin. This method is frequently used for the purpose
of wiping out a deficit, an impairment of capital, and is, of course,
a _real_ profit as distinguished from a _book_ profit. Similarly,
additional payments made by common shareholders to convert their
holdings into preferred shares are a realized profit and should be
recorded as part of the margin.
_Capital Profits and Bonuses._ Capital profits, as discussed in
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter