Psychopathia sexualis: With especial reference to contrary sexual instinct
3. Mental treatment, in the sense of combating homo-sexual, and
2408 words | Chapter 41
encouraging hetero-sexual, feelings and impulses.
The most important part of the treatment lies in fulfilling the third
indication, particularly with reference to onanism.
Only in very few cases, where acquired contrary sexual instinct has not
progressed far, can the fulfillment of 1 and 2 be sufficient, as the
following case, fully reported by the author in the _Irrenfreund_, 1884,
No. 1, proves:—
Case 132. Count Z., aged 51, of psychopathic mother, was early sent to
a military school, and there was taught onanism. He developed well,
and had normal sexual feelings, but, as a result of masturbation, he
became somewhat neurasthenic in his seventeenth year. He enjoyed
intercourse with women, was married at twenty-five, but after a year
more became neurasthenic, and absolutely lost his inclination for
women. In its place came contrary sexual instinct. Involved in an
accusation for high treason, he was sent to prison for two years, and
then to Siberia for five years. In these seven years, under the
influence of continued masturbation, neurasthenia and contrary sexual
instinct constantly increased. With his freedom restored at the age of
thirty-five, the patient began to visit all kinds of health-resorts on
account of his great neurasthenia; and this has since been his
occupation. In all these years his abnormal sexual feeling has not
changed in any way. For the most part, he lived away from his wife,
whom, it is true, he esteemed for her mental qualities; though he
avoided her, as he did every other woman. His contrary sexual feeling
is purely platonic. “Friendship,” sweet embraces, and kisses sufficed
him. Pollutions, which occasionally occurred, were induced by
lascivious dreams which had for subject persons of his own sex. Also,
during the day, the most beautiful woman had no charm for him, while
simply the sight of handsome men induced erection and ejaculation.
Only athletes and male dancers in the circus and _ballet_ interested
him. At times of greater excitability, even masculine statues gave him
erections. Now and again he resumed his old vice of masturbation. This
man of æsthetic culture had a horror of pederasty.
He felt, always, that his perverse sexual feeling was something
abnormal, without, however, in his apparently much weakened libido and
virility, feeling unhappy.
The examination gave the usual findings of neurasthenia. Development,
manner, and attire presented nothing remarkable. Electrical massage
was unusually successful. After a few sittings the patient was
mentally and physically much better. After twenty sittings libido was
again awakened, not in the same way, but normally, as the patient had
felt until his twenty-fifth year. Lascivious dreams were concerned
only with women; and one day the patient joyfully gave the information
that he had had coitus, and that he had had the same natural feeling
in it that he had had twenty-six years before. He then began to live
with his wife again, and hoped that he was lastingly freed from
neurasthenia and contrary sexual instinct. His hope was fulfilled for
the six years during which I was able to keep the patient under
observation.
As a rule, physical treatment, even though it be re-inforced morally by
good advice with reference to the avoidance of masturbation, the
repression of homo-sexual feelings and impulses, and the encouragement
of hetero-sexual desires, will not prove sufficient, even in cases of
acquired contrary sexual instinct.
Here a method of mental treatment—hypnotic suggestion—is all that can
bring benefit.
The following case is interesting; and it is an example of successful
auto-suggestion that gives encouragement for the milder forms of the
anomaly:—
Case 133. _Autobiography of a Psychical Hermaphrodite. Successful
Struggle against Homo-sexual Inclinations made by the Patient
himself._—“My father once had a stroke, but has recovered save for
paralysis of the face. My mother was very anæmic and melancholic. Both
suffered severely with hæmorrhoids, and my father ascribed to this
trouble the lumbar pain with which he suffered from time to time after
his marriage.
“I am, if I may so express myself, a passive character. When a child,
I indulged in all kinds of fancies, religious as well as others. I
suffered with incontinence of urine, and it is said that in sleep I
handled my genitals, so that my father fastened my hands to the bed!
(I was then a mere child, and had not masturbated.) I was always very
shy and embarrassed in social intercourse. When about fourteen or
fifteen years old, I was seduced into onanism. The impulse and desire
for women, occurring in connection with the awakening sexual feeling,
were, in reality, only of a platonic nature; I was also without the
society of ladies. When about eighteen, I attempted to satisfy my
sexual desire in the natural way, more in obedience to a feeling of
curiosity than from inner longing. Since that time, without having
experienced any real inclination for women, as often as possible I
have satisfied my desire by means of sexual intercourse.
“Soon after puberty I became very anæmic, and appeared much older than
I really was. Then came melancholic and peculiar ideas. It was a
delight to me to fancy myself humiliated in the extreme. It may be of
interest to add that, at that time, I was troubled with religious
doubts, and only later found the courage to rise above religions. I
fell in love with young men. At first I opposed these ideas; later
they became so powerful that I became a genuine urning. Women seemed
to me to be human beings of the second class. I was in a state of
despair. My sickened soul was filled with tædium vitæ and thoughts
inimical to humanity. One day I read: ‘What will it come to?’ And ere
I knew it, I was a socialist; but an ideal one. Life again had value
for me, for I had an ideal,—the joyous struggle for the social
elevation of the proletariat. This caused a powerful revolution in me.
As in my best years (from the age of sixteen to seventeen), I took
interest in art, particularly in dramatic art. I am, at the present
time, writing a play and a story, and I am occupied with the grandest
thoughts. I read a remark of Schlegel’s concerning Sophocles, who was
indebted to his physical exercise for his energy and creative power,
and to music for his artistic proportions. In another place I read:
‘The dramatist must, above all things, be mentally intact.’ This
depressed me; for my contrary sexual feelings could not arise in a
perfectly normal mind.
“I thought of having myself treated hypnotically; but shame held me
back. Then I said to myself that I was a weakling, indeed, to have so
little confidence in myself, and began in earnest to combat my
abnormal desires. At the same time, I struggled against my nervousness
by leading the proper kind of a life. I rowed, fenced, and was much in
the open air; and I was delighted when, at last, I awoke and seemed to
be an entirely different man. When I thought of the time from my
twentieth to my twenty-sixth year, it seemed to me that, during those
years, a strange and depressive being had been dwelling within me.
“I was astonished that the handsomest rider or the trimmest waiter
excited in me almost no interest; even the muscular masons had no
effect on me. I was disgusted when I thought that, at one time, such
men had seemed handsome to me. My self-respect increased; I am
good-natured, but my character is entirely active. Since my twentieth
year my appearance has steadily improved. My appearance now
corresponds perfectly with my years. There were recurrences of my
abnormal inclinations, to be sure; but I struggled against them
energetically. I satisfy my libido only by means of natural
intercourse, and I hope that, by continuing to lead a proper life, my
pleasure in natural coitus will increase.”
As a rule, only suggestion coming from a second person, and that by
means of hypnosis, promises any success. In such cases, the object of
post-hypnotic suggestion is to remove the impulse to masturbation and
homo-sexual feelings and impulses, and to encourage hetero-sexual
feelings with a sense of virility. A prerequisite is, of course, the
possibility to induce hypnosis of sufficient intensity. It is,
unfortunately, in these very cases of neurasthenia that this is
impossible, since they are often excited, embarrassed, and in no
condition to concentrate their thoughts.
Thus, in a case reported by me in the _International. Centralblatt für
die Physiologie und Pathologie der Harn- und Sexualorgane_, Bd. i, Heft
2, p. 58, it was impossible for me to induce hypnosis, though the
patient desired it, and did everything to make it successful. By reason
of the great benefit that can be given to such unfortunates, and with
Ladame’s case in view (_v. infra_), in the future, in all such cases,
everything should be done to bring about hypnosis,—the only means of
salvation. The result, in the three following cases, was satisfactory:—
Case 134. _Contrary Sexual Instinct Acquired through
Masturbation._—Mr. X., merchant, aged 29. Father’s parents healthy.
Nothing nervous in father’s family. Father was an irritable, peevish
old man. One brother of the father was a man-about-town, and died
unmarried. Mother died in third confinement, when the patient was six
years old; she had a deep, rough, masculine voice, and coarse
appearance. Of the children, one brother is irritable, “melancholic,”
and indifferent to women.
When a child patient had scarlet fever with delirium. Until his
fourteenth year he was light-hearted and social, but, after that,
quiet, solitary, and “melancholic.” The first trace of sexual feeling
appeared in his tenth or eleventh year, and at that time he learned
masturbation from other boys, and practiced mutual onanism with them.
At the age of thirteen or fourteen, ejaculation for the first time.
Patient has felt no evil results of onanism until the last three
months.
In school he learned easily, but was troubled with headaches. After
the age of twenty, pollutions, in spite of daily practice of onanism.
With pollutions, “procreative” dreams, as man and wife might perform
the act, occurred. In his seventeenth year he was seduced into mutual
onanism by a man having a love for men. He found satisfaction in this,
inasmuch as he was always very passionate sexually. It was a long time
before the patient again sought new opportunities for intercourse with
males. He did it simply to rid himself of semen. He felt no friendship
or love for the person with whom he had intercourse. He felt
satisfaction only when he played the passive _rôle_,—when
manustupration was practiced on him. When the act was once completed,
he had no respect for the individual. If it happened that, later, he
came to respect the man, then he ceased to indulge in the act with
him. Later it became indifferent to him whether he masturbated or had
masturbation practiced on him. When he himself practiced onanism, he
always thought of pleasing men practicing onanism on him during the
act. He preferred a hard, rough hand.
The patient thought that, had he not been led astray, he would have
arrived at a natural mode of satisfaction of his sexual desires. He
never felt love for his own sex, though he had pleased himself with
the thought of loving men. At first he had had sensual inclinations
toward the opposite sex. He had taken pleasure in dancing, and he had
been pleased with women, but he had taken more pleasure in the figure
than the face. Too, he had had erections at the sight of women that
pleased him. He had never attempted coitus, for fear of infection;
whether he was potent or not with women, he did not know. He thought
he could be so no longer, because his feeling for women had grown
cold, especially during late years.
While previously, in his sensual dreams, he had had ideas of both men
and women, of late years he had dreamed only of approaches to men; he
could not remember that he had dreamed, in late years, of sensual
relations with a woman. At the theatre, as well as in the circus and
_ballet_, the feminine figure had always interested him. In museums
masculine and feminine statues had affected him equally.
Patient is a great smoker, a beer-drinker, loves male society, and is
a gymnast and skater. Anything dandified was repugnant to him, and he
had never felt any desire to please men; he would even have preferred
to please women.
He now felt his position to be painful, because onanism had obtained
the upper hand. Masturbation, that had previously been practiced
without evil effects, now began to disclose its bad results.
Since July, 1889, he had suffered with neuralgia of the testicles. The
pain occurred particularly at night; and at night there was also
trembling (increased reflex excitability).
Sleep was not refreshing, and he would wake up with pain in the
testicles. He was inclined, now, to indulge more frequently in
onanism. He was afraid of the consequences of the habit. He hoped that
his sexual life might still be turned into normal channels. Now, he
thought of the future; he had a relation with a girl, who was
attractive to him, and the thought to possess her as a wife was
pleasing.
For five days he had abstained from onanism, but he could scarcely
believe that he would be able, with his own strength, to overcome the
habit. Of late he had been very much depressed, having lost all desire
for work, and become tired of life.
Patient is tall, powerful, well nourished, and has a thick growth of
beard. Skull and skeleton normal. Knee-jerks very prompt; deep
reflexes in upper extremities much increased. Pupils dilated, equal,
and act promptly. Carotids of equal calibre; hyperæsthesia urethræ;
cords and testicles not sensitive; genitals normal.
The patient was calmed, and given hope for the future, provided that
he give up onanism and attempt to transfer his sexual desires from
persons of his own sex to females.
Hip-baths (24° to 20° R.); ext. secal. conut. aquos., 0.5; antipyrin,
1.0 (_pro die_); pot. brom., 4.0 (evenings), were ordered.
December 13th. To-day the patient came, in a disturbed condition of
mind, complaining that, unaided, he was unable to resist the impulse
to masturbate, and he asked for help.
A trial of hypnosis induced a condition of deep lethargy in the
patient.
He was given the following suggestions:—
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter