Renaissance in Italy, Volume 1 (of 7) by John Addington Symonds
1573. Of the rest we hear only of prolonged torture before stupid and
970 words | Chapter 39
malignant judges, of falsified evidence and of contradictory
confessions. What he really said and chose to stand by, what he
retracted, what he shrieked out in the delirium of the rack, and what
was falsely imputed to him, no one now can settle.[2] Though the spirit
was strong, the flesh was weak; he had the will but not the nerve to be
a martyr. At ten o'clock on the 23d of May 1498 he was led forth
together with brother Salvestro, the confidant of his visions, and
brother Domenico, his champion in the affair of the ordeal, to a stage
prepared in the Piazza.[3] These two men were hanged first. Savonarola
was left till the last. As the hangman tied the rope round his neck, a
voice from the crowd shouted: 'Prophet, now is the time to perform a
miracle!' The Bishop of Vasona, who conducted the execution, stripped
his friar's frock from him, and said, 'I separate thee from the Church
militant and triumphant.' Savonarola, firm and combative even at the
point of death, replied, 'Militant yes: triumphant, no: _that_ is not
yours.' The last words he uttered were, 'The Lord has suffered as much
for me.' Then the noose was tightened round his neck. The fire beneath
was lighted. The flames did not reach his body while life was in it; but
those who gazed intently thought they saw the right hand give the sign
of benediction. A little child afterwards saw his heart still whole
among the ashes cast into the Arno; and almost to this day flowers have
been placed every morning of the 23d of May upon the slab of the Piazza
where his body fell.
[1] There seems to be no doubt that this Ordeal by Fire was
finally got up by the Compagnacci with the sanction of the
Signory, who were anxious to relieve themselves by any means of
Savonarola. The Franciscan chosen to enter the flames together
with Fra Domenico was a certain Giuliano Rondinelli. Nardi
calls him Andrea Rondinelli.
[2] Nardi, lib. ii. vol. i. p. 128, treats the whole matter of
Savonarola's confessions under torture with good sense. He
says: 'Avendo domandato il frate quello che diceva e affermava
delle sue esamine fatte infino a quel di, rispose, che ciò ch'
egli aveva ne' tempi passati detto e predetto era la pura
verita, e che quello di che s'era ridetto e aveva ritratto, era
tutto falso e era seguito per il dolor grande e per la paura
che egli aveva de' tormenti, e che di nuovo si ridirebbe e
ritratterebbe tante volte, quante ci fusse di nuovo tormentato,
perciò che si conosceva molto debole e inconstante nel
sopportare i supplicii.' Burchard, in his Diary, reports the
childish, foul, malignant gossip current in Rome. This may be
read in the 'Preuves et Observations' appended to the _Memoirs_
of De Comines, vol. v. p. 512. See the Marchese Gino Capponi's
_Storia della Firenze_ (tom. ii. pp. 248-51) for a critical
analysis of the depositions falsely ascribed to Savonarola.
[3] There is a curious old picture in the Pinacoteca of Perugia
which represents the burning of the three friars. The whole
Piazza della Signoria is shown, with the houses of the
fifteenth century, and without the statues which afterwards
adorned it. The spectator fronts the Palazzo, and has to his
extreme right the Loggia de' Lanzi. The center of the square is
occupied by a great circular pile of billets and fagots, to
which a wooden bridge of scaffolding leads from the left angle
of the Polazzo. From the middle of the pile rises a pole, to
which the bodies of the friars in their white clothes are
suspended. Sta Maria del Fiore, the Badia tower, and the
distant hills above Fiesole complete a scene which is no doubt
accurate in detail.
Thus died Savonarola: and immediately he became a saint. His sermons and
other works were universally distributed. Medals in his honor were
struck. Raphael painted him among the Doctors of the Church in the
Camera della Segnatura of the Vatican. The Church, with strange
inconsistency, proposed to canonize the man whom she had burned as a
contumacious heretic and a corrupter of the people. This canonization
never took place: but many Dominican Churches used a special office
with his name and in his honor.[1] A legend similar to that of S.
Francis in its wealth of mythical details embalmed the memory of even
the smallest details of his life. But, above all, he lived in the hearts
of the Florentines. For many years to come his name was the watchword of
their freedom; his prophecies sustained their spirit during the siege of
1528;[2] and it was only by returning to his policy that Niccolo Capponi
and Francesco Carducci ruled the people through those troublous times.
The political action of Savonarola forms but a short episode in the
history of Florence. His moral revival belongs to the history of popular
enthusiasm. His philosophical and theological writings are chiefly
interesting to the student of post-medæival scholasticism. His attitude
as a monastic leader of the populace, attempting to play the old game
whereby the factious warfare of a previous age had been suspended by
appeals to piety, and politicians had looked for aid outside the nation,
was anachronistic. But his prophecy, his insight into the coming of a
new era for the Church and for Italy, is a main fact in the psychology
of the Renaissance.
[1] _Officio del Savonarola_, with preface by Cesare Guasti.
Firenze, 1863.
[2] Guicciardini, in his _Ricordt_, No. i., refers the
incredible obstinacy of the Florentines at this period in
hoping against all hope and reason to Savonarola: 'questa
ostinazione ha causata in gran parte a fede di non potere
perire, secondo le predicazioni di Fra Jeronirno da Ferrara.'
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter