The Epidemics of the Middle Ages by J. F. C. Hecker and John Caius
CHAPTER II.
7473 words | Chapter 26
DANCING MANIA IN ITALY.
SECT. 1.—TARANTISM.
It was of the utmost advantage to the St. Vitus’s dancers that
they made choice of a favourite patron saint; for, not to mention
that people were inclined to compare them to the possessed with
evil spirits, described in the Bible, and thence to consider them
as innocent victims to the power of Satan, the name of their great
intercessor recommended them to general commiseration, and a magic
boundary was thus set to every harsh feeling which might otherwise have
proved hostile to their safety. Other fanatics were not so fortunate,
being often treated with the most relentless cruelty whenever the
notions of the middle ages either excused or commanded it as a
religious duty[244].
Thus, passing over the innumerable instances of the burning of witches,
who were, after all, only labouring under a delusion, the Teutonic
knights in Prussia not unfrequently condemned those maniacs to the
stake who imagined themselves to be metamorphosed into wolves[245]—an
extraordinary species of insanity, which, having existed in Greece,
before our era, spread, in process of time, over Europe, so that it
was communicated not only to the Romaic, but also to the German and
Sarmatian nations, and descended from the ancients, as a legacy of
affliction to posterity. In modern times, Lycanthropy, such was the
name given to this infatuation, has vanished from the earth, but it
is nevertheless well worthy the consideration of the observer of
human aberrations, and a history of it by some writer who is equally
well acquainted with the middle ages as with antiquity is still a
desideratum[246]. We leave it, for the present, without further
notice, and turn to a malady most extraordinary in all its phenomena,
having a close connexion with the St. Vitus’s dance, and, by a
comparison of facts, which are altogether similar, affording us an
instructive subject for contemplation. We allude to the disease called
Tarantism, which made its first appearance in Apulia, and thence spread
over the other provinces of Italy, where, during some centuries, it
prevailed as a great epidemic. In the present times it has vanished,
or at least has lost altogether its original importance, like the St.
Vitus’s dance, lycanthropy, and witchcraft.
SECT. 2.—MOST ANCIENT TRACES.—CAUSES.
The learned Nicholas Perotti[247] gives the earliest account of this
strange disorder. Nobody had the least doubt that it was caused by
the bite of the _tarantula_[248][249], a ground-spider common in
Apulia; and the fear of this insect was so general, that its bite was
in all probability much oftener imagined, or the sting of some other
kind of insect mistaken for it, than actually received. The word
_tarantula_ is apparently the same as _terrantola_, a name given by
the Italians to the stellio of the old Romans, which was a kind of
lizard[250], said to be poisonous, and invested by credulity with such
extraordinary qualities, that, like the serpent of the Mosaic account
of the Creation, it personified, in the imaginations of the vulgar, the
notion of cunning, so that even the jurists designated a cunning fraud
by the appellation of a “stellionatus”[251]. Perotti expressly assures
us that this reptile was called by the Romans _tarantula_; and since
he himself, who was one of the most distinguished authors of his time,
strangely confounds spiders and lizards together, so that he considers
the Apulian tarantula, which he ranks among the class of spiders, to
have the same meaning as the kind of lizard, called ἀσκαλαβώτης[252],
it is the less extraordinary that the unlearned country people of
Apulia should confound the much dreaded ground-spider with the fabulous
star-lizard[253], and appropriate to the one the name of the other. The
derivation of the word tarantula, from the city of Tarentum, or the
river Thara, in Apulia[254], on the banks of which this insect is said
to have been most frequently found, or at least its bite to have had
the most venomous effect, seems not to be supported by authority. So
much for the name of this famous spider, which, unless we are greatly
mistaken, throws no light whatever upon the nature of the disease in
question. Naturalists who, possessing a knowledge of the past, should
not misapply their talents by employing them in establishing the dry
distinction of forms, would find here much that calls for research, and
their efforts would clear up many a perplexing obscurity.
Perotti states that the tarantula, that is, the spider so called,
was not met with in Italy in former times, but that in his day it
had become common, especially in Apulia, as well as in some other
districts. He deserves, however, no great confidence as a naturalist,
notwithstanding his having delivered lectures in Bologna on medicine
and other sciences[255]. He at least has neglected to prove his
assertion, which is not borne out by any analogous phenomenon observed
in modern times with regard to the history of the spider species. It
is by no means to be admitted that the tarantula did not make its
appearance in Italy before the disease ascribed to its bite became
remarkable, even though tempests more violent than those unexampled
storms which arose at the time of the Black Death[256] in the middle
of the fourteenth century had set the insect world in motion; for the
spider is little, if at all, susceptible of those cosmical influences
which at times multiply locusts and other winged insects to a wonderful
extent, and compel them to migrate.
The symptoms which Perotti enumerates as consequent on the bite of the
tarantula agree very exactly with those described by later writers.
Those who were bitten, generally fell into a state of melancholy, and
appeared to be stupified, and scarcely in possession of their senses.
This condition was, in many cases, united with so great a sensibility
to music, that, at the very first tones of their favourite melodies,
they sprang up, shouting for joy, and danced on without intermission,
until they sank to the ground exhausted and almost lifeless. In others,
the disease did not take this cheerful turn. They wept constantly, and
as if pining away with some unsatisfied desire, spent their days in the
greatest misery and anxiety. Others, again, in morbid fits of love,
cast their longing looks on women, and instances of death are recorded,
which are said to have occurred under a paroxysm of either laughing or
weeping.
From this description, incomplete as it is, we may easily gather that
tarantism, the essential symptoms of which are mentioned in it, could
not have originated in the fifteenth century, to which Perotti’s
account refers; for that author speaks of it as a well known malady,
and states that the omission to notice it by older writers, was to be
ascribed solely to the want of education in Apulia, the only province
probably where the disease at that time prevailed. A nervous disorder
that had arrived at so high a degree of development, must have been
long in existence, and doubtless had required an elaborate preparation
by the concurrence of general causes.
The symptoms which followed the bite of venomous spiders were well
known to the ancients, and had excited the attention of their best
observers, who agree in their descriptions of them. It is probable
that among the numerous species of their phalangium[257], the Apulian
tarantula is included, but it is difficult to determine this point with
certainty, more especially, because in Italy the tarantula was not the
only insect which caused this nervous affection, similar results being
likewise attributed to the bite of the scorpion. Lividity of the whole
body as well as of the countenance, difficulty of speech, tremor of
the limbs, icy coldness, pale urine, depression of spirits, headache,
a flow of tears, nausea, vomiting, sexual excitement, flatulence,
syncope, dysuria, watchfulness, lethargy, even death itself, were cited
by them as the consequences of being bitten by venomous spiders, and
they made little distinction as to their kinds. To these symptoms we
may add the strange rumour, repeated throughout the middle ages, that
persons who were bitten, ejected by the bowels and kidneys, and even by
vomiting, substances resembling a spider’s web.
Nowhere, however, do we find any mention made that those affected felt
an irresistible propensity to dancing, or that they were accidentally
cured by it. Even Constantine of Africa, who lived 500 years after
Aëtius, and as the most learned physician of the school of Salerno,
would certainly not have passed over so acceptable a subject of
remark, knows nothing of such a memorable course of this disease
arising from poison, and merely repeats the observations of his
Greek predecessors[258]. Gariopontus[259], a Salernian physician of
the eleventh century, was the first to describe a kind of insanity,
the remote affinity of which to the tarantula disease is rendered
apparent by a very striking symptom. The patients in their sudden
attacks behaved like maniacs, sprang up, throwing their arms about
with wild movements, and, if perchance a sword was at hand, they
wounded themselves and others, so that it became necessary carefully
to secure them. They imagined that they heard voices, and various
kinds of sounds, and if, during this state of illusion, the tones of
a favourite instrument happened to catch their ear, they commenced a
spasmodic dance, or ran with the utmost energy which they could muster
until they were totally exhausted. These dangerous maniacs, who, it
would seem, appeared in considerable numbers, were looked upon as a
legion of devils, but on the causes of their malady this obscure writer
adds nothing further than that he believes (oddly enough) that it may
sometimes be excited by the bite of a mad dog. He calls the disease
Anteneasmus, by which is meant no doubt the Enthusiasmus of the Greek
physicians[260]. We cite this phenomenon as an important forerunner
of Tarantism, under the conviction that we have thus added to the
evidence that the development of this latter must have been founded
on circumstances which existed from the twelfth to the end of the
fourteenth century; for the origin of Tarantism itself is referrible,
with the utmost probability, to a period between the middle and the
end of this century, and is consequently contemporaneous with that of
the St. Vitus’s dance (1374). The influence of the Roman Catholic
religion, connected as this was, in the middle ages, with the pomp of
processions, with public exercises of penance, and with innumerable
practices which strongly excited the imaginations of its votaries,
certainly brought the mind to a very favourable state for the reception
of a nervous disorder. Accordingly, so long as the doctrines of
Christianity were blended with so much mysticism, these unhallowed
disorders prevailed to an important extent, and even in our own days
we find them propagated with the greatest facility where the existence
of superstition produces the same effect in more limited districts, as
it once did among whole nations. But this is not all. Every country in
Europe, and Italy perhaps more than any other, was visited during the
middle ages by frightful plagues, which followed each other in such
quick succession, that they gave the exhausted people scarcely any
time for recovery. The oriental bubo-plague ravaged Italy[261] sixteen
times between the years 1119 and 1340. Small-pox and measles were still
more destructive than in modern times, and recurred as frequently. St.
Anthony’s fire was the dread of town and country; and that disgusting
disease, the leprosy, which, in consequence of the crusades, spread
its insinuating poison in all directions, snatched from the paternal
hearth innumerable victims who, banished from human society, pined away
in lonely huts, whither they were accompanied only by the pity of the
benevolent and their own despair. All these calamities, of which the
moderns have scarcely retained any recollection, were heightened to
an incredible degree by the Black Death[262], which spread boundless
devastation and misery over Italy. Men’s minds were everywhere morbidly
sensitive; and as it happens with individuals whose senses, when they
are suffering under anxiety, become more irritable, so that trifles are
magnified into objects of great alarm, and slight shocks, which would
scarcely affect the spirits when in health, give rise in them to severe
diseases, so was it with this whole nation, at all times so alive to
emotions, and at that period so sorely pressed with the horrors of
death.
The bite of venomous spiders, or rather the unreasonable fear of its
consequences, excited at such a juncture, though it could not have
done so at an earlier period, a violent nervous disorder, which,
like St. Vitus’s dance in Germany, spread by sympathy, increasing
in severity as it took a wider range, and still further extending
its ravages from its long continuance. Thus, from the middle of the
fourteenth century, the furies of _the Dance_ brandished their scourge
over afflicted mortals; and music, for which the inhabitants of Italy,
now probably for the first time, manifested susceptibility and talent,
became capable of exciting ecstatic attacks in those affected, and then
furnished the magical means of exorcising their melancholy.
SECT. 3.—INCREASE.
At the close of the fifteenth century we find that Tarantism had
spread beyond the boundaries of Apulia, and that the fear of being
bitten by venomous spiders had increased. Nothing short of death
itself was expected from the wound which these insects inflicted, and
if those who were bitten escaped with their lives, they were said to
be seen pining away in a desponding state of lassitude. Many became
weak-sighted or hard of hearing, some lost the power of speech, and
all were insensible to ordinary causes of excitement. Nothing but
the flute or the cithern afforded them relief[263]. At the sound of
these instruments they awoke as it were by enchantment, opened their
eyes, and moving slowly at first, according to the measure of the
music, were, as the time quickened, gradually hurried on to the most
passionate dance. It was generally observable that country people,
who were rude, and ignorant of music, evinced on these occasions an
unusual degree of grace, as if they had been well practised in elegant
movements of the body; for it is a peculiarity in nervous disorders
of this kind, that the organs of motion are in an altered condition,
and are completely under the control of the over-strained spirits.
Cities and villages alike resounded throughout the summer season with
the notes of fifes, clarinets, and Turkish drums; and patients were
everywhere to be met with who looked to dancing as their only remedy.
Alexander ab Alexandro[264], who gives this account, saw a young man in
a remote village who was seized with a violent attack of Tarantism. He
listened with eagerness and a fixed stare to the sound of a drum, and
his graceful movements gradually became more and more violent, until
his dancing was converted into a succession of frantic leaps, which
required the utmost exertion of his whole strength. In the midst of
this over-strained exertion of mind and body the music suddenly ceased,
and he immediately fell powerless to the ground, where he lay senseless
and motionless until its magical effect again aroused him to a renewal
of his impassioned performances.
At the period of which we are treating there was a general conviction,
that by music and dancing the poison of the Tarantula was distributed
over the whole body, and expelled through the skin, but that if there
remained the slightest vestige of it in the vessels, this became a
permanent germ of the disorder, so that the dancing fits might again
and again be excited _ad infinitum_ by music. This belief, which
resembled the delusion of those insane persons who, being by artful
management freed from the imagined causes of their sufferings, are but
for a short time released from their false notions, was attended with
the most injurious effects: for in consequence of it those affected
necessarily became by degrees convinced of the incurable nature of
their disorder. They expected relief, indeed, but not a cure, from
music; and when the heat of summer awakened a recollection of the
dances of the preceding year, they, like the St. Vitus’s dancers
of the same period before St. Vitus’s day, again grew dejected
and misanthropic, until, by music and dancing, they dispelled the
melancholy which had become with them a kind of sensual enjoyment.
Under such favourable circumstances it is clear that Tarantism must
every year have made further progress. The number of those affected by
it increased beyond all belief, for whoever had either actually been,
or even fancied that he had been, once bitten by a poisonous spider or
scorpion, made his appearance annually wherever the merry notes of the
Tarantella resounded. Inquisitive females joined the throng and caught
the disease, not indeed from the poison of the spider, but from the
mental poison which they eagerly received through the eye; and thus
the cure of the _Tarantati_ gradually became established as a regular
festival of the populace, which was anticipated with impatient delight.
Without attributing more to deception and fraud than to the peculiar
nature of a progressive mental malady, it may readily be conceived
that the cases of this strange disorder now grew more frequent.
The celebrated Matthioli[265], who is worthy of entire confidence,
gives his account as an eye-witness. He saw the same extraordinary
effects produced by music as Alexandro, for, however tortured with
pain, however hopeless of relief the patients appeared, as they lay
stretched on the couch of sickness, at the very first sounds of those
melodies which made an impression on them—but this was the case only
with the Tarantellas composed expressly for the purpose—they sprang
up as if inspired with new life and spirit, and, unmindful of their
disorder, began to move in measured gestures, dancing for hours
together without fatigue, until, covered with a kindly perspiration,
they felt a salutary degree of lassitude, which relieved them for a
time at least, perhaps even for a whole year, from their dejection and
oppressive feeling of general indisposition. Alexandro’s experience of
the injurious effects resulting from a sudden cessation of the music
was generally confirmed by Matthioli. If the clarinets and drums ceased
for a single moment, which, as the most skilful players were tired out
by the patients, could not but happen occasionally, they suffered their
limbs to fall listless, again sank exhausted to the ground, and could
find no solace but in a renewal of the dance. On this account care was
taken to continue the music until exhaustion was produced; for it was
better to pay a few extra musicians, who might relieve each other,
than to permit the patient, in the midst of this curative exercise, to
relapse into so deplorable a state of suffering. The attack consequent
upon the bite of the Tarantula, Matthioli describes as varying much in
its manner. Some became morbidly exhilarated, so that they remained
for a long while without sleep, laughing, dancing, and singing in a
state of the greatest excitement. Others, on the contrary, were drowsy.
The generality felt nausea and suffered from vomiting, and some had
constant tremors. Complete mania was no uncommon occurrence, not to
mention the usual dejection of spirits and other subordinate symptoms.
SECT. 4.—IDIOSYNCRACIES.—MUSIC.
Unaccountable emotions, strange desires and morbid sensual irritations
of all kinds, were as prevalent as in the St. Vitus’s dance and similar
great nervous maladies. So late as the sixteenth century patients
were seen armed with glittering swords which, during the attack, they
brandished with wild gestures, as if they were going to engage in a
fencing match[266]. Even women scorned all female delicacy[267] and,
adopting this impassioned demeanour, did the same; and this phenomenon,
as well as the excitement which the Tarantula dancers felt at the sight
of any thing with metallic lustre, was quite common up to the period
when, in modern times, the disease disappeared[268].
The abhorrence of certain colours and the agreeable sensations produced
by others, were much more marked among the excitable Italians than was
the case in the St. Vitus’s dance with the more phlegmatic Germans.
Red colours, which the St. Vitus’s dancers detested, they generally
liked, so that a patient was seldom seen who did not carry a red
handkerchief for his gratification, or greedily feast his eyes on
any articles of red clothing worn by the bystanders. Some preferred
yellow, others black colours, of which an explanation was sought,
according to the prevailing notions of the times, in the difference
of temperaments[269]. Others again were enraptured with green; and
eye-witnesses describe this rage for colours as so extraordinary, that
they can scarcely find words with which to express their astonishment.
No sooner did the patients obtain a sight of the favourite colour
than, new as the impression was, they rushed like infuriated animals
towards the object, devoured it with their eager looks, kissed and
caressed it in every possible way, and gradually resigning themselves
to softer sensations, adopted the languishing expression of enamoured
lovers, and embraced the handkerchief, or whatever other article it
might be, which was presented to them, with the most intense ardour,
while the tears streamed from their eyes as if they were completely
overwhelmed by the inebriating impression on their senses.
The dancing fits of a certain Capuchin friar in Tarentum excited so
much curiosity, that Cardinal Cajetano proceeded to the monastery,
that he might see with his own eyes what was going on. As soon as the
monk, who was in the midst of his dance, perceived the spiritual prince
clothed in his red garments, he no longer listened to the Tarantella
of the musicians, but with strange gestures endeavoured to approach
the Cardinal, as if he wished to count the very threads of his scarlet
robe, and to allay his intense longing by its odour. The interference
of the spectators, and his own respect, prevented his touching it, and
thus the irritation of his senses not being appeased, he fell into a
state of such anguish and disquietude, that he presently sank down in a
swoon, from which he did not recover until the Cardinal compassionately
gave him his cape. This he immediately seized in the greatest ecstacy,
and pressed now to his breast, now to his forehead and cheeks, and then
again commenced his dance as if in the frenzy of a love fit[270].
At the sight of colours which they disliked, patients flew into the
most violent rage, and, like the St. Vitus’s dancers when they saw red
objects, could scarcely be restrained from tearing the clothes of those
spectators who raised in them such disagreeable sensations[271].
Another no less extraordinary symptom was the ardent longing for the
sea which the patients evinced. As the St. John’s dancers of the
fourteenth century saw, in the spirit, the heavens open and display
all the splendour of the saints, so did those who were suffering under
the bite of the Tarantula feel themselves attracted to the boundless
expanse of the blue ocean, and lost themselves in its contemplation.
Some songs, which are still preserved, marked this peculiar longing,
which was moreover expressed by significant music, and was excited even
by the bare mention of the sea[272]. Some, in whom this susceptibility
was carried to the greatest pitch, cast themselves with blind fury into
the blue waves[273], as the St. Vitus’s dancers occasionally did into
rapid rivers. This condition, so opposite to the frightful state of
hydrophobia, betrayed itself in others only in the pleasure afforded
them by the sight of clear water in glasses. These they bore in their
hands while dancing, exhibiting at the same time strange movements,
and giving way to the most extravagant expressions of their feelings.
They were delighted also when, in the midst of the space allotted for
this exercise, more ample vessels, filled with water, and surrounded by
rushes and water plants, were placed, in which they bathed their heads
and arms with evident pleasure[274]. Others there were who rolled about
on the ground, and were, by their own desire, buried up to the neck in
the earth, in order to alleviate the misery of their condition, not to
mention an endless variety of other symptoms which showed the perverted
action of the nerves.
All these modes of relief, however, were as nothing in comparison with
the irresistible charms of musical sound. Attempts had indeed been
made in ancient times to mitigate the pain of sciatica[275], or the
paroxysms of mania[276], by the soft melody of the flute, and, what
is still more applicable to the present purpose, to remove the danger
arising from the bite of vipers[277] by the same means. This, however,
was tried only to a very small extent. But after being bitten by the
Tarantula, there was, according to popular opinion, no way of saving
life except by music, and it was hardly considered as an exception
to the general rule, that every now and then the bad effects of a
wound were prevented by placing a ligature on the bitten limb, or
by internal medicine, or that strong persons occasionally withstood
the effects of the poison, without the employment of any remedies at
all[278]. It was much more common, and is quite in accordance with the
nature of so exquisite a nervous disease, to hear accounts of many,
who, when bitten by the Tarantula, perished miserably because the
Tarantella, which would have afforded them deliverance, was not played
to them[279]. It was customary, therefore, so early as the commencement
of the seventeenth century, for whole bands of musicians to traverse
Italy during the summer months, and, what is quite unexampled either in
ancient or modern times, the cure of the _Tarantati_ in the different
towns and villages was undertaken on a grand scale. This season of
dancing and music was called “the women’s little carnival,”[280] for
it was women more especially who conducted the arrangements; so that
throughout the whole country they saved up their spare money, for the
purpose of rewarding the welcome musicians, and many of them neglected
their household employments to participate in this festival of the
sick. Mention is even made of one benevolent lady (Mita Lupa) who had
expended her whole fortune on this object[281].
The music itself was of a kind perfectly adapted to the nature of
the malady, and it made so deep an impression on the Italians, that
even to the present time, long since the extinction of the disorder,
they have retained the Tarantella, as a particular species of music
employed for quick lively dancing. The different kinds of Tarantella
were distinguished, very significantly, by particular names, which had
reference to the moods observed in the patients. Whence it appears that
they aimed at representing by these tunes, even the idiosyncracies of
the mind as expressed in the countenance. Thus there was one kind of
Tarantella which was called “Panno rosso,” a very lively impassioned
style of music, to which wild dithyrambic songs were adapted; another,
called “Panno verde,” which was suited to the milder excitement of the
senses, caused by green colours, and set to Idyllian songs of verdant
fields and shady groves. A third was named “Cinque tempi:” a fourth
“Moresca,” which was played to a Moorish dance; a fifth, “Catena”
and a sixth, with a very appropriate designation, “Spallata,” as if it
were only fit to be played to dancers who were lame in the shoulder.
This was the slowest and least in vogue of all[282]. For those who
loved water they took care to select love songs, which were sung to
corresponding music, and such persons delighted in hearing of gushing
springs and rushing cascades and streams[283]. It is to be regretted
that on this subject we are unable to give any further information, for
only small fragments of songs, and a very few Tarantellas, have been
preserved, which belong to a period so remote as the beginning of the
seventeenth, or at furthest the end of the sixteenth century[284].
The music was almost wholly in the Turkish style (aria Turchesca),
and the ancient songs of the peasantry of Apulia, which increased in
number annually, were well suited to the abrupt and lively notes of
the Turkish drum and the shepherd’s pipe. These two instruments were
the favourites in the country, but others of all kinds were played in
towns and villages, as an accompaniment to the dances of the patients
and the songs of the spectators. If any particular melody was disliked
by those affected, they indicated their displeasure by violent gestures
expressive of aversion. They could not endure false notes, and it
is remarkable that uneducated boors, who had never in their lives
manifested any perception of the enchanting power of harmony, acquired,
in this respect, an extremely refined sense of hearing, as if they had
been initiated into the profoundest secrets of the musical art[285].
It was a matter of every day’s experience, that patients showed a
predilection for certain Tarantellas, in preference to others, which
gave rise to the composition of a great variety of these dances. They
were likewise very capricious in their partialities for particular
instruments; so that some longed for the shrill notes of the trumpet,
others for the softest music produced by the vibration of strings[286].
Tarantism was at its greatest height in Italy in the seventeenth
century, long after the St. Vitus’s Dance of Germany had disappeared.
It was not the natives of the country only who were attacked by this
complaint. Foreigners of every colour and of every race, negroes,
gipsies, Spaniards, Albanians, were in like manner affected by it[287].
Against the effects produced by the Tarantula’s bite, or by the sight
of the sufferers, neither youth nor age afforded any protection; so
that even old men of ninety threw aside their crutches at the sound of
the Tarantella, and, as if some magic potion, restorative of youth and
vigour, were flowing through their veins, joined the most extravagant
dancers[288]. Ferdinando saw a boy five years old seized with the
dancing mania[289], in consequence of the bite of a tarantula, and,
what is almost past belief, were it not supported by the testimony of
so credible an eye-witness, even deaf people were not exempt from this
disorder, so potent in its effect was the very sight of those affected,
even without the exhilarating emotions caused by music[290].
Subordinate nervous attacks were much more frequent during this
century than at any former period, and an extraordinary icy coldness
was observed in those who were the subjects of them; so that they
did not recover their natural heat until they had engaged in violent
dancing[291]. Their anguish and sense of oppression forced from them
a cold perspiration; the secretion from the kidneys was pale[292],
and they had so great a dislike to every thing cold, that when water
was offered them they pushed it away with abhorrence. Wine, on the
contrary, they all drank willingly, without being heated by it, or
in the slightest degree intoxicated[293]. During the whole period
of the attack they suffered from spasms in the stomach, and felt a
disinclination to take food of any kind. They used to abstain some time
before the expected seizures from meat and from snails, which they
thought rendered them more severe[294], and their great thirst for wine
may, therefore, in some measure, be attributable to the want of a more
nutritious diet; yet the disorder of the nerves was evidently its chief
cause, and the loss of appetite, as well as the necessity for support
by wine, were its effects. Loss of voice, occasional blindness[295],
vertigo, complete insanity, with sleeplessness, frequent weeping
without any ostensible cause, were all usual symptoms. Many patients
found relief from being placed in swings or rocked in cradles[296];
others required to be roused from their state of suffering by severe
blows on the soles of their feet; others beat themselves, without any
intention of making a display, but solely for the purpose of allaying
the intense nervous irritation which they felt; and a considerable
number were seen with their bellies swollen[297], like those of the
St. John’s dancers, while the violence of the intestinal disorder
was indicated in others by obstinate constipation or diarrhœa and
vomiting[298]. These pitiable objects gradually lost their strength
and their colour, and creeping about with injected eyes, jaundiced
complexions, and inflated bowels, soon fell into a state of profound
melancholy, which found food and solace in the solemn tolling of the
funeral bell, and in an abode among the tombs of cemeteries, as is
related of the Lycanthropes of former times.
The persuasion of the inevitable consequences of being bitten by
the Tarantula, exercised a dominion over men’s minds which even the
healthiest and strongest could not shake off. So late as the middle
of the sixteenth century, the celebrated Fracastoro found the robust
bailiff of his landed estate groaning, and, with the aspect of a person
in the extremity of despair, suffering the very agonies of death,
from a sting in the neck, inflicted by an insect which was believed
to be a Tarantula. He kindly administered without delay, a potion of
vinegar and Armenian bole, the great remedy of those days for the
plague and all kinds of animal poisons, and the dying man was, as if by
a miracle, restored to life and the power of speech[299]. Now, since
it is quite out of the question that the bole could have any thing to
do with the result in this case, notwithstanding Fracastoro’s belief
in its virtues, we can only account for the cure by supposing, that a
confidence in so great a physician prevailed over this fatal disease
of the imagination, which would otherwise have yielded to scarcely any
other remedy except the Tarantella. Ferdinando was acquainted with
women who, for thirty years in succession, had overcome the attacks
of this disorder by a renewal of their annual dance—so long did they
maintain their belief in the yet undestroyed poison of the Tarantula’s
bite, and so long did that mental affection continue to exist, after it
had ceased to depend on any corporeal excitement[300].
Wherever we turn we find that this morbid state of mind prevailed, and
was so supported by the opinions of the age, that it needed only a
stimulus in the bite of the Tarantula, and the supposed certainty of
its very disastrous consequences, to originate this violent nervous
disorder. Even in Ferdinando’s time there were many who altogether
denied the poisonous effects of the Tarantula’s bite, whilst they
considered the disorder, which annually set Italy in commotion, to be
a melancholy depending on the imagination[301]. They dearly expiated
this scepticism, however, when they were led, with an inconsiderate
hardihood, to test their opinions by experiment; for many of them
became the subjects of severe Tarantism, and even a distinguished
prelate, Jo. Baptist Quinzato, Bishop of Foligno, having allowed
himself, by way of a joke, to be bitten by a Tarantula, could obtain
a cure in no other way than by being, through the influence of the
Tarentella, compelled to dance[302]. Others among the clergy, who
wished to shut their ears against music, because they considered
dancing derogatory to their station, fell into a dangerous state of
illness by thus delaying the crisis of the malady, and were obliged at
last to save themselves from a miserable death by submitting to the
unwelcome but sole means of cure[303]. Thus it appears that the age was
so little favourable to freedom of thought, that even the most decided
sceptics, incapable of guarding themselves against the recollection
of what had been presented to the eye, were subdued by a poison, the
powers of which they had ridiculed, and which was in itself inert in
its effect.
SECT. 5.—HYSTERIA.
Different characteristics of morbidly excited vitality having been
rendered prominent by Tarantism in different individuals, it could
not but happen that other derangements of the nerves would assume the
form of this, whenever circumstances favoured such a transition.
This was more especially the case with hysteria, that proteiform and
mutable disorder, in which the imaginations, the superstitions and the
follies of all ages have been evidently reflected. The “Carnevaletto
delle Donne” appeared most opportunely for those who were hysterical.
Their disease received from it, as it had at other times from other
extraordinary customs, a peculiar direction; so that whether bitten
by the tarantula or not, they felt compelled to participate in the
dances of those affected, and to make their appearance at this
popular festival, where they had an opportunity of triumphantly
exhibiting their sufferings. Let us here pause to consider the kind
of life which the women in Italy led. Lonely, and deprived by cruel
custom of social intercourse, that fairest of all enjoyments, they
dragged on a miserable existence. Cheerfulness and an inclination
to sensual pleasures passed into compulsory idleness, and, in many,
into black despondency[304]. Their imaginations became disordered—a
pallid countenance and oppressed respiration bore testimony to their
profound sufferings. How could they do otherwise, sunk as they were
in such extreme misery, than seize the occasion to burst forth from
their prisons, and alleviate their miseries by taking part in the
delights of music. Nor should we here pass unnoticed a circumstance
which illustrates, in a remarkable degree, the psychological nature
of hysterical sufferings, namely, that many chlorotic females, by
joining the dancers at the Carnevaletto, were freed from their spasms
and oppression of breathing for the whole year, although the corporeal
cause of their malady was not removed[305]. After such a result, no one
could call their self-deception a mere imposture, and unconditionally
condemn it as such.
This numerous class of patients certainly contributed not a little to
the maintenance of the evil, for their fantastic sufferings, in which
dissimulation and reality could scarcely be distinguished even by
themselves, much less by their physicians, were imitated, in the same
way as the distortions of the St. Vitus’s dancers, by the impostors of
that period. It was certainly by these persons also that the number
of subordinate symptoms was increased to an endless extent, as may
be conceived from the daily observation of hysterical patients, who,
from a morbid desire to render themselves remarkable, deviate from the
laws of moral propriety. Powerful sexual excitement had often the most
decided influence over their condition. Many of them exposed themselves
in the most indecent manner, tore their hair out by the roots, with
howling and gnashing of their teeth; and when, as was sometimes the
case, their unsatisfied passion hurried them on to a state of frenzy,
they closed their existence by self-destruction; it being common at
that time for these unfortunate beings to precipitate themselves into
the wells[306].
It might hence seem that, owing to the conduct of patients of this
description, so much of fraud and falsehood would be mixed up with the
original disorder, that having passed into another complaint, it must
have been itself destroyed. This, however, did not happen in the first
half of the seventeenth century; for as a clear proof that Tarantism
remained substantially the same and quite unaffected by Hysteria,
there were in many places, and in particular at Messapia, fewer women
affected than men, who in their turn were, in no small proportion, led
into temptation by sexual excitement[307]. In other places, as for
example at Brindisi, the case was reversed, which may, as in other
complaints, be in some measure attributable to local causes. Upon the
whole it appears, from concurrent accounts, that women by no means
enjoyed the distinction of being attacked by Tarantism more frequently
than men.
It is said that the cicatrix of the tarantula bite, on the yearly or
half-yearly return of the fit, became discoloured[308], but on this
point the distinct testimony of good observers is wanting to deprive
the assertion of its utter improbability.
It is not out of place to remark here, that about the same time that
Tarantism attained its greatest height in Italy, the bite of venomous
spiders was more feared in distant parts of Asia likewise, than it
had ever been within the memory of man. There was this difference,
however, that the symptoms supervening on the occurrence of this
accident were not accompanied by the Apulian nervous disorder, which,
as has been shown in the foregoing pages, had its origin rather in the
melancholic temperament of the inhabitants of the south of Italy, than
in the nature of the tarantula poison itself. This poison is therefore
doubtless to be considered only as a remote cause of the complaint,
which, but for that temperament, would be inadequate to its production.
The Persians employed a very rough means of counteracting the bad
consequences of a poison of this sort. They drenched the wounded person
with milk, and then, by violent rotatory motion in a suspended box,
compelled him to vomit[309].
SECT. 6.—DECREASE.
The Dancing Mania, arising from the tarantula bite, continued, with all
those additions of self-deception, and of the dissimulation which is
such a constant attendant on nervous disorders of this kind, through
the whole course of the seventeenth century. It was indeed gradually
on the decline, but up to the termination of this period, showed such
extraordinary symptoms, that Baglivi, one of the best physicians of
that time, thought he did a service to science by making them the
subject of a dissertation[310]. He repeats all the observations of
Ferdinando, and supports his own assertions by the experience of his
father, a physician at Lecce, whose testimony, as an eye-witness, may
be admitted as unexceptionable[311].
The immediate consequences of the tarantula bite, the supervening
nervous disorder, and the aberrations and fits of those who suffered
from Hysteria, he describes in a masterly style, nor does he ever
suffer his credulity to diminish the authenticity of his account, of
which he has been unjustly accused by later writers.
Finally, Tarantism has declined more and more in modern times, and is
now limited to single cases. How could it possibly have maintained
itself unchanged in the eighteenth century, when all the links which
connected it with the middle ages had long since been snapped asunder?
Imposture[312] grew more frequent, and wherever the disease still
appeared in its genuine form, its chief cause, namely, a peculiar cast
of melancholy, which formerly had been the temperament of thousands,
was now possessed only occasionally by unfortunate individuals. It
might therefore not unreasonably be maintained, that the Tarantism of
modern times bears nearly the same relation to the original malady, as
the St. Vitus’s dance which still exists, and certainly has all along
existed, bears, in certain cases, to the original dancing mania of the
dancers of St. John.
To conclude. Tarantism, as a real disease, has been denied _in toto_,
and stigmatized as an imposition, by most physicians and naturalists,
who in this controversy have shown the narrowness of their views and
their utter ignorance of history. In order to support their opinion
they have instituted some experiments, apparently favourable to it,
but under circumstances altogether inapplicable, since, for the most
part, they selected, as the subjects of them, none but healthy men,
who were totally uninfluenced by a belief in this once so dreaded
disease. From individual instances of fraud and dissimulation, such as
are found in connexion with most nervous affections without rendering
their reality a matter of any doubt, they drew a too hasty conclusion
respecting the general phenomenon, of which they appeared not to know,
that it had continued for nearly four hundred years, having originated
in the remotest periods of the middle ages. The most learned and the
most acute among these sceptics is Serao the Neapolitan[313]. His
reasonings amount to this, that he considers the disease to be a very
marked form of melancholia, and compares the effect of the tarantula
bite upon it to stimulating, with spurs, a horse which is already
running. The reality of that effect he thus admits, and therefore
directly confirms what in appearance only he denies[314]. By shaking
the already vacillating belief in this disorder he is said to have
actually succeeded in rendering it less frequent, and in setting bounds
to imposture[315]; but this no more disproves the reality of its
existence, than the oft-repeated detection of imposition has been able,
in modern times, to banish magnetic sleep from the circle of natural
phenomena, though such detection has, on its side, rendered more rare
the incontestible effects of animal magnetism. Other physicians and
naturalists[316] have delivered their sentiments on Tarantism, but as
they have not possessed an enlarged knowledge of its history, their
views do not merit particular exposition. It is sufficient for the
comprehension of every one, that we have presented the facts freed from
all extraneous speculation.
Reading Tips
Use arrow keys to navigate
Press 'N' for next chapter
Press 'P' for previous chapter